How about 1.5yrs and maybe you can do both - do a split stay between value and deluxe? We no longer go dawn to dark at the parks, and really enjoy our time at the resorts so now we prefer the deluxes, but when we did go commando ie: last time at POP, it was the perfect choice for us, and we ended our vacation at Hard Rock Hotel mostly hanging out at the great pool. In our experience, there really isn't any point in dishing out the big bucks on a resort if all you do is sleep there - I have to admit to pressuring DH this year to upgrade from POR to AKL as I really would like to stay there, and I think it will be a long time until we go back to WDW - if we didn't stay there I think it really would have affected my enjoyment of the trip, so we are tightening our belts even more and will do so for the next year to afford it. All depends on the type of holiday you want - good luck in your decision!