Would love opinions POR Royal Room v. GF (and months)

ktlm

DIS Veteran
Joined
Jun 20, 2008
Messages
9,701
I'm torn right now, and I would love to get some opinions from my fellow Disers. We've stayed at POR and really liked it, but that was years ago pre-kid when it was Dixie Landings. We stayed at GF last year and we like it too. (honestly DH and I prefer the Poly, but DD (6) goes absolutely nuts over GF and GF is gorgeous during the Christmas season).

So currently I have to decide between an October trip staying at POR in a Royal Room river view or an early December trip staying garden view at GF. The kicker is that the price is just about the same. (GF is a bounce back). I'm figuring the crowds are about the same. We have been in December the last few years, and find the crowd levels to be really managable. Here are the pros and cons I can come up with.

POR Royal Room -October
Pros
1. DD loves Princesses and would love the Royal rooms. I'm sure her love of Princesses won't last forever.
2. Food and Wine at Epcot. We've never been

3. MNSSP. We've never been. I'm a little worried as how to DD will be at the Halloween party as she generally doesn't like too much with the villians or anything "creepy", but she is interested in going.

4. Fall break so DD would miss very little school. ( She will be in first grade, but she hasn't even finished kindergarten and her reading is already at a 2nd or 3rd grade level and her math at an end of 1st grade level so academically it shouldn't be a big deal to pull her out in December).

Cons

1. POR at a "GF price". We have stayed at GF, Poly, and WL in recent years, and always at a discount price, whether it be bounceback, pin code, or website special offer. We would be paying as much for this trip as we have to stay at the deluxes, actually we would be paying more than we paid for either of our two trips at WL.

2. Rooms are significantly smaller than GF or Poly (that's correct isn't it?)

3. Only bus service to the parks (how are those buses? That was our only complaint with GF- the bus service was terrible. We've only stayed there once, but on trips we didn't stay there and just popped over to eat, we always thought it was really bad too. We have always been fine with the bus service from the Poly and WL.)


GF- Early December

Pros

1. DD also loves GF. She thinks it is Cinderella's hotel because of 1900 Park Fare and Cinderella has always been her favorite Princess.

2. WDW is beautiful at Christmas, and they have all the special Christmas events and characters. (I love Santa Goofy at AK).

3. GF is gorgeous at Christmas

4. MVMCP- We all really like that party. (I love those tin soldiers in the parade and the castle show. DD loves all the characters).

5. Taking advantage of our bounceback discount.

6. The boat/monorail to MK, and the monorail to Epcot

7. Our times of going in the Christmas season in the future are going to be pretty limited because I don't know how many more years I will be willing or able to pull DD out of school for a week.

Cons

1. DD would miss a week of school (We did it this year, and the school is good about it, but I'm not that comfortable with it. Again, as stated above academically it isn't going to be a big deal, so it's probably pretty much just me that feels a little funny about it)

2. No trying out the Royal Rooms

3. We've never been in the fall before, so we wouldn't be trying something new.

3. No food and wine or MNSSHP.


I'd love to hear opinions of what you guys would pick in my situation, and also any other pros or cons you can come up with. I know the Royal Rooms have been open a couple of weeks now, so I would love to hear from anyone who has already been lucky enough to stay in one. I just keep going back and forth and can't make up my mind, and DH is the same way! Thanks!
 
Honest? :rotfl:

If I could afford the Grand Floridian, there would be no talking me out of it to switch to a moderate. None. No way, no how.

Now obviously you have a little one to think about, but if you can take her out of school (which it sounds like you can) I would still do Grand Floridian. And your pros for Grand Floridian are better than the pros for POR. (in my opinion)

Either way, have a fantastic trip!!! I'm jealous!

(also I'm biased, I've never been to Disney at Christmas and I really want to, but boyfriend wants to go when he is guaranteed swimming!)
 
I would do October in a Royal Room. Fall discounts aren't out yet... they will come.

Food/Wine, MNSSHP, Very little time in "princess" mode left, Less school to miss, the rooms will still be new and in good condition. It will also be warm enough to swim or go to the water parks.... in December sometimes it is iffy. You can still go to breakfast or dinner at the GF!
 
GF no contest. :thumbsup2 I've stayed at both too, and to me, there's no comparison. And for the money being equal, I'd rather be on the monorail. That alone eliminates buses to 2 parks. If you want to keep the princess theme, you can always do a little surprise like we did ..... our DD was 4 1/2 at the time. I brought two princess dresses with us and when she was asleep, we put them out on her bed w/ a note from Tinkerbell inviting her to breakfast in the castle. it was priceless when she woke up. You can make your own Princess atmosphere...plus, you'll also have the 1900 PF Cinderella dinner right in the GF. You can't get more royal than that! :thumbsup2

If you aren't going to spend a ton of time in the room, is it then more important to get the Royal Room or the better location? (plus the GF at Christmas time is so beautiful from what I hear) And the Christmas party. We did the Halloween party, which was SO much fun.

Good luck in your choice!!
 
Honest? :rotfl:

If I could afford the Grand Floridian, there would be no talking me out of it to switch to a moderate. None. No way, no how.

:laughing: I know, I know...but those Royal Rooms are just so stinking cute! I remember POR being pretty too with the river and little bridge. You have to talk the boyfriend into going at Christmas sometime! I love it there that time of year. Swimming is iffy though. We've been there when we were sweating and when we were wearing coats in December, you just never know! Seems like somebody's always in the pool though-maybe he can be that one person out there!

LuvLuvLuv- You make a good argument for October. Trying that food and wine festival is something I'm having a hard time giving up! And fall is the one time of the year we have never been...but then again, I really do love the Christmas season at WDW.

You are right Sydney's Mom, we really don't spend that much time in the room...but then again DD just goes nuts over hotel rooms for some reason. Very cute surprise for your DD! GF is absolutely gorgeous at Christmas. We also did really enjoy being close to 1900 Park Fare so we could clean up in the room for a minute before dinner. That dinner is a must for DD, my huge Cinderella fan. See you almost had me, but then you went and said how fun the Halloween party was!

What to do, what to do.... Well, at least it is a good decision to have to make either way. Maybe it would be completely ridiculous to spend the same price for POR as I could do for a stay at GF even if it does mean DD will miss less school...but then again maybe a discount will come out..... UGH---- All I know is that I need to make a decision because if I pick October I need to start thinking about park days and ADRs pretty soon!
 
Normally I would think you were nuts comparing the two and GF would win without a backward glance. :confused3

However, I'm assuming this is not your last Disney trip so you will have more chances to hit the GF. This could be your last chance for your DD to be really into a princess room (depending on how often you go). I know my daughter would not have been excited by a princess room by the time she hit 9. Don't get me wrong, she would have thought it was cute, but it wouldn't have the WOW factor going for it. Those moments are so fleeting, you'll never get them back once you've missed them. I don't think you will regret not going to GF because it will always be there, but you may regret not staying in a princess room while it is still magical for your daughter.


In addition, I'm all for one trying out new things, so this will give you a whack at MNSSHP and the Food & Wine festival (which should NEVER be undervalued :rotfl2:).

And while I was at POR in October, I would keep my eye out for a bounce back offer and if there is one, book the GF for the next trip. :banana:
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom