IME, both meals I have tried were great. I felt that spending just a few dollars more than I would of for lunch was not a big problem at all. I liked that I had several hours to pick up the meal and the WOC FPs at my leisure, That is a huge benefit of the picnics.
Matt which meals did you have?
I'm considering the picnics for our trip in 2 weeks.
But I'm not sure I want to do them....we may just grab FPs in the morning and see how that goes. 
Which color passes do you get? Red or Blue? I can't remember I think both are offered for the picnic lunches (but that you have to take what they give you...)
The Disney site says:
"All picnic meals include dessert, choice of beverage and one reusable World of Color commemorative tote bag for every 4 picnic meals ordered."
I am ordering 5 meals, am I getting 4 bags or 1 bag?
I think that means you are getting two bags. If four meals fit into one bag and you have 5 meals, then it would take 2 bags.
The Disney site says:
"All picnic meals include dessert, choice of beverage and one reusable World of Color commemorative tote bag for every 4 picnic meals ordered."
I am ordering 5 meals, am I getting 4 bags or 1 bag?