Wish to Magic Side By Side Review

[DCL58]

Sorry you had such a pain in the butt experience. I think a lot of us would love to get your take on going from the first ship to one of the newest ships

Not the OP, but we sailed on the Treasure and then 2 weeks on the Magic this summer. We much preferred the Magic!

 

[Girl of the South]

Why did you prefer the Magic? Top 5 reasons? (If you don’t mind . . . )

 

[DCL58]

Why did you prefer the Magic? Top 5 reasons? (If you don’t mind . . . )

1) adult sundeck on the Treasure
2) no walking track on the Treasure
3) interior of the Magic has the typical DCL nautical feel - blue/red. Treasure has themes
4) Magic is smaller and has 3 separate elevators - not a fan of the 2 on the Treasure. Always seemed to be lines for everything on the Treasure. Never saw any on the Magic in 15 nights.
5) trivia on the Treasure in Triton’s - that is too small for the number of people who want to attend. Sarabi also filled up for popular activities. Didn’t have the same experience on the Magic.

I could keep going! But we did enjoy the dining and lounge experiences on the Treasure. We sail the Treasure again in 3 weeks, but that is probably it for us. Back to the fantasy - which beats the Magic and the Treasure.

 

[CamColt]

I'll agree with the above poster we definitely prefer the Magic over the Treasure (or Wish) overall but there are parts of the Treasure we prefer over Magic (Coco> Rapunzel's). But we still prefer the Dream and Fantasy over the Magic/Wonder. The Satellite Falls area just cannot be beat in my book and not having to deal with a full blown show during dinner is nice.

 

[Girl of the South]

Thanks! So much of it is layout/design. I have heard the food is better on the Treasure. I haven't been on any of the newer ships but always liked the decor and design of the cabins on the classic ships. The Magic was my first . . . .