Despite having received a bazillion responses from Windsor Hills, I think we ended up making an irrational decision. We had narrowed it down to a bunch of houses all under the 3000. Then before booking I searched VRBO one last time and found a themed house. The owner was very responsive to my emails and answered all the questions we had but his price was 3700 for 17 nights. After speaking to the owner we ended up booking but now I can't help but think about all the responses we had between 3000-3500 that I had all deleted without looking because they were too high. And this house doesn't even include pool heat...
But on the plus side the house is booked...
But on the plus side the house is booked...