Wilderness Lodge Room Reservation Problem (and Solution!) at Check-In

Status
Not open for further replies.

nipizarro

Earning My Ears
Joined
Jan 18, 2003
Messages
15
My family and I are recently back from a 3 night stay at the Wilderness Lodge (Courtyard View, Winter Thaw Rate), and have an experience to share relating to room assignment promises and switches (with a good ending!).

We arrived at WL at 2:00 pm and attempted to check-in. We were told that our faxed room requests had been received (high floor, unobstructed view of lake & water pageant, non-Villa view), as a result of which a room was blocked-out for us. The only problem was that the room would not be ready until after 3:00 pm. I was then offered an "equivalent" room but on a lower floor and on the south rather than north wing. I declined, and was given a phone number to call back to check on my room's readiness. We were more than willing to wait for our preferred room, despite our exhaustion from having just flown in from NJ and driven from Tampa!

At 6:00 pm, we returned and were brought to our supposedly "blocked out" room which, also supposedly, met all of our requests. Hmm...not quite...we had a 6th floor room with a straight-on view of the green metal roof of the main lodge building. If one went onto the balcony and stretched outward to the left while leaning out, some specs of the lagoon could be seen.

Needless to say, I went to the front desk and complained. My response, amazingly, was that "no one knew" of any "blocked out" room for us, and "we have some new cast members at the front desk who may not have known what they were saying." What a thing to tell a guest! Amazingly, I was also told, "well, maybe because you didn't come back until 6:00 we might have given the room to someone else, because people were checking in all day" -- YIKES, so much for comprehension of the concept of "blocking out" a room! I was not amused whatsoever by this room assignment switch.

The next hour and a half was spent looking at two other rooms, neither meeting the requests which had supposedly been granted in assigning the initial room. The first was a south wing lakeside view, directly over the pool bar, with no view whatsoever of any of the rest of the resort - yes it overlooked the lake (and geyser, which was out of service during our entire stay), but it was also dark and isolated. We declined it, and ended up in room 3007 (north wing, view of waterfall from bed, behind weeping willow trees, partial (and obstructed) view of the lagoon). We "settled" for this room because we wanted to invest no more time resolving this room fiasco. The next morning, however, I wrote a letter to the hotel manager, conveying my speculation that our room was given to someone else as we awaited its preparation.

An amazing response: a very professionally handled acceptance of culpability ("we certainly are responsible for dropping the ball on this one"), and compensation for our inconvenience by giving us complimentary one day ultimate park hopper passes (good for up to 20 years in the future) for each member of our family (totalling 4 passes). More important than this compensation was a statement accepting responsibility and a promise to address the room switch with all involved employees! I could not have been more satisfied.

One last great experience: Having only 3 days to spend this vacation, we carefully planned which park we would see on which
day. We did not, however, think to ask whether the Buzz Lightyear ride in the MK (my 3 year old son's ONLY reason for living!) would be closed for renovation, which of course it was - and set to reopen on the day we LEFT Disney!!!! Thinking I would be laughed at with my request, but willing to do so anyway, I explained the situation to the Guest Services at the inside entracnce to the MK, and - ready for this - they allowed us to come in the next day, and as long as we were out by 1pm, there was no cost (this was handled by us purchasing 4 tickets and then returning them for a full refund if out by 1pm). Being a Saturday (and President's Day Weekend), it actually took us 2 hours from beginning of Fast Pass to end of ride, but my son's face made it all worth it!!!

Just thought I'd share these 2 experiences!
 
We were told that our faxed room requests had been received (high floor, unobstructed view of lake & water pageant, non-Villa view), as a result of which a room was blocked-out for us. The only problem was that the room would not be ready until after 3:00 pm. I was then offered an "equivalent" room but on a lower floor and on the south rather than north wing.

Unless things have changed in the last couple of months, this is where they dropped the ball. I've never been able to get a CM at check-in to divulge whether or not our room requests were met. They're not supposed to, and for the very reason you experienced. They may well have had your room blocked, but for some reason they changed it and gave the room to someone else. If they don't tell you that you have what you asked for, you'll never know this. As I'm sure you know, room requests aren't guaranteed and they let guests make requests as a courtesy only.

It does sound like Disney did their best to satisfy you after the problems you experienced. I've yet to be disappointed in the way they handle any problem I've ever had.
 
Nice to hear that they actually accepted some responsibility here. We're going in Aug and your room requests sound just like ours!!! I know these are just 'requests' but we're hoping for some magic. Glad you had a good overall experience.
 
I'm glad everything worked out for you.

I don't see how they could have changed your room assignment after you checked in, however. When we check in and the room isn't ready, we are still given room keys. The keys are pre-programmed for our room, but since we aren't told the room number, we obviously can't use them until after we make the call to find out the room number. Sometimes we have to call more than once or twice because housekeeping hasn't finished cleaning the room. We never have to get our room keys re-programmed, all we needed to know was whcih room was ours. Therefore, the room itself was assigned to us at check in, even though it wasn't ready for us t that time.

I think the CM just made a mistake in telling you all of your requests were granted. They weren't. No one "gave your room away" between the time you checked in and the time you found out your room number, unless you had to stop at the front desk and get your room keys re-programmed.
 

...I just LOVE happy endings!!!:bounce: :Pinkbounc :bounce:

(Looks like some pixie dust was sprinkled YOUR way!!!;) )
 
To CarolMN:

Yes, the room was given away to someone else, as was later confirmed by the hotel manager. The keys were not given to us until we subsequently arrived at the check-in desk at 6pm. We had a copy of the map on which the initial check-in agent located and diagrammed our "blocked-out" room, which was not even remotely close to the room subsequently given to us.
 
To CarolMN:

Yes, the room was given away to someone else, as was later confirmed by the hotel manager. The keys were not given to us until we subsequently arrived at the check-in desk at 6pm. We had a copy of the map on which the initial check-in agent located and diagrammed our "blocked-out" room, which was not even remotely close to the room subsequently given to us. Amazing how helpful it was to have this map - in essence, it gave us written confirmation of the room switch.
 
Originally posted by nipizarro
To CarolMN:

Yes, the room was given away to someone else, as was later confirmed by the hotel manager. The keys were not given to us until we subsequently arrived at the check-in desk at 6pm. We had a copy of the map on which the initial check-in agent located and diagrammed our "blocked-out" room, which was not even remotely close to the room subsequently given to us. Amazing how helpful it was to have this map - in essence, it gave us written confirmation of the room switch.

Wow! We always get keys when we check in, even when the room isn't ready. After we call for the room number, we can go right to the room - no need to stop at the front desk again.

Either the WL has a different procedure than the other WDW Resorts we have stayed at, or that CM really messed up. Anyway, I'm sorry you had to go through all that. Hope your next trip is perfect!
 
Hello all.....Disney always seems to make it right when they make a mistake...a few years ago we were booked for 8 nights in the Contemporary.....when I made the reservation I thought I was getting a tower room.....when we checked in on Saturday they told us we were in the garden wings.....ofcourse I was not a happy camper.....my wife had been sick and we thought we might have to cancel the trip...luckily we got to go.....so, they tried to get us in a tower room for the 8 nights....put us in a tower for 4 nights but needed the room back on Wednesday....so that night we get a knock on the door, and what is it....milk and cookies from Mickey and Minnee to apologize for the mix up.....the next night we get back to the room and a fruit basket is waiting for us....and unfortunately on Wednesday we had to move....so they moved us to a suite in the wing.....and another fruit basket that night to say thank you.....we had a great time....and were very impressed on how they handled everything!
Tom
 
Thanks for sharing this! It's a great story, not only because things worked out for you, but it also shows a positive side to the Disney resorts. I am glad everything worked out for you and the extra passes are a great bonus!
 
When checking into CSR saturday morning, the CM did say that our room in casitas had been assigned, but was not yet ready. I did send a fax reqesting casitas. We left and came back around 12:30. Of course, the room wasn't ready, but we were so tired that the CM gave us a room in Cabanas. So, she did actually tell us that our room had been "assigned", but I don't remember if she used the word "requests". It was certainly implied in the conversation, though.
 
Hi All
I am so glad that everything worked out for your trip to the Wilderness Lodge. Compensation of park tickets seemed a bit much for a hotels supposed mistake, but I can tell you once a room has been assigned to a reservation and the keys given to a guest, it is improbable that the room was given away. It is highly probable that your faxed request was ignored. Some room assignment cast members do not always TRY their best to meet request, and I apologize for that, but a request is just that, a request.Most people think that since they requested something tthat they will get the request. It doesn't always work that way at Disney or in life.The complainers get compenstaion, whether earned or not..In my experience I'd have to say not. As a managers or general managers saying that they dropped the ball is a way of saying that anything you want to make you happy.Which is a great busines ideal, but many people take advantage of, I think in my own opinion, this was compensation not deserved. As most of you know my from my helpfull comments and advice on these boards. I could not let this one go, I am sorry.
Have a Magical Day.......
 
It is great that you had a wonderful visit. It speaks volumes for the Wilderness Lodge management that it places such a high priority on guest satisfaction. In my travels, that is what separates the average from the superior hotels.

As for the park CM, it never fails during one of our trips that we have a great expereince with a park CM. That is what distingushes Disney.
 
As most of you know my from my helpfull comments and advice on these boards.

I thought I'd take the chance and jump in and say thank you so much for all your help on our trip this past Christmas! We had a great time at the WL and everything there was just perfect. It was undoubtedly the best service we've ever had at any resort. Your kind help was more than expected and greatly appreciated!


On topic, I didn't realize the person in question actually got the keys to their room. I agree completely with what you had to say on this subject. Their generosity in this case is just more proof as to how far Disney goes to make their guests happy.

At any rate, I never thanked you after returning home, and I wanted to be sure and tell you how much we appreciated all you did and continue to do on these boards. THANKS!!!!!
 
Thanks Peachgirl, I'm glad I was of help to you. I know you appreciated it...You have that personality...The Wilderness Lodge is a Magical Resort and I love my role there...What type of room do you have at OKW?

Have a Mgical Day.....
 
Peachgirl...sorry I left this out in my last post..Whenever you checkin in, or Pre check in, you are given room keys which are preaasigned to your room, if your room is ready, you are given the room number. If your room is not ready, you are given a card to call for your room number..At that point the room cannot be removed from your reservation and given to another guest..If anyone tells you otherwise it is bogus..If the front desk had "given away " your room, you would have to have new keys made, since the original keys were precoded to open up the room at check in...Let me know when you are coming again...


Have a Magical Day.......
 
What type of room do you have at OKW?


We have a 2 bedroom villa. I know the OKW villas are supposed to be really great, and I'm sure they are, but I'm going to miss the more personal feel at WL!

We hope to make "winter" trips a tradition and I can't think of a better resort in the winter time than the Wilderness Lodge. I can still hear that gorgeous music they played throughout the whole resort.....sigh!!!

Since our room was ready when we arrived (before noon!) I didn't know exactly how the room key thing worked. Thanks for explaining it. Besides, we paid no attention whatsoever at check-in, we were too busy taking in everything!
 
Hmm - I too could not let your reply go unresponded to. You are now the second person to surmise, with supposed confidence, that my room was not given away. Pretty amazing given the hotel manager's confirmation that it was - NOT a likely thing for him to have said if in fact the room were not given away! Regarding your opinions on whether the compensation was appropriate or excessive, I must again use the word "amazing" to describe a fellow-disney fan's need to assess and degrade what was a POSITIVE letter to this Board describing a POSITIVE (and in my mind TOTALLY APPROPRIATE) experience of compensation by a hotel for its errors. More importantly, if you carefully read my initial post, I state that the most impressive outcome of this situation was the hotel's acknowledgment of culpability - sorry that you feel your (uninformed) assessment of the situation is more accurate.
 
Pretty amazing given the hotel manager's confirmation that it was - NOT a likely thing for him to have said if in fact the room were not given away!
I state that the most impressive outcome of this situation was the hotel's acknowledgment of culpability

Actually, it's very likely the the manager would say just what he did whether it was "accurate" or not. If instead he had said, "We didn't do anything wrong, we didn't give your room away, but just to be nice we're going to go ahead and give you some free passes", what would your reaction have been? Would you have walked away a happy, satisfied guest? From your post, it seems what is most impressive to you is not the compensation, but the fact that the manager admitted that they were wrong and you were right. Disney knows that most people feel just that way.

Did the manager lie to you? Heavens no! That doesn't happen at DisneyWorld....he just gave you an answer heavily laced with pixie dust!;)
 
It seems like no other subject gets people riled up more than someone getting compensation for something....maybe the mug question gets people as riled up.....but the bottom line in my opinion is that mistakes happen all the time.....Disney I would say more than any other business tries to make it right....however...they will not ever give away the store.....we were part of the Magic cruise that was cancelled due to illness on 11/30.....many people had to scramble to get new reservations, put on the Wonder.....just have a 7 day vacation in Disney World....and we talked to many people on the ship we ended up on who had been scheduled to sail with us on 11/30......Disney made different deals with different people to work around everyone's vacation plans....some people got put up in a hotel for 3 nights and 4 nights on the Wonder, some people got the 7 days at Disney World, some got food vouchers for there land portion, some got passes to the parks and some others did not. They tried to make people happy, and in most cases everyone was pretty satisfied. There were some people who were very vocal about what they should have or could have.....but all of us on the cancelled cruise got 50% off our next cruise....some people wanted the 50% off what they paid in November, but all got 50 % off the going rate of when they chose to sail. I myself work for a supermarket in New York, and our policy is to make the customer happy all the time, unless we feel positively we are being scammed......so if someone brings back the fat from a roast beef....the first time they get a new roast beef....next time it may not be the same.....but Disney wants people coming back....time and time again....but they don't want to give up the store since everything they do ends up on these boards....if they felt it the right thing to do to give one day passes to a family, they must have felt they deserved it....and I myself don't begrudge anyone getting something for an inconvience or a by a cast member....unfortunately there are people that don't always agree what Disney does....but in my book for the most part they always do the right thing....and I am never jealous of what someone else gets.
Tom
 
Status
Not open for further replies.














Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top