We are on the dining plan too and going in September for our 25th wedding anniversary. Our best friends are going with us for this trip. And, although on the dining plan, we are paying out of pocket and going to Fulton's for our "special" dinner. You will see differing points of view on this restaurant--good and bad--but we have never had a bad experience and have always had great service and food. Unfortunately, I can make no other suggestions at Downtown Disney because we have never dined at any of the other establishments.