The 50mm f/1.8 wont auto focus on the OP's camera which is the Nikon D40.

Why exactly? It has no issue on my D70s, autofocus works like a champ. What's different on the D40??![]()
D40/D40x/D60 do not have a focus motor in the body; 50/1.8D does not have a focus motor in the lens. Thus, no AF. Only lenses with focus motors in the lens (Nikon AF-S, Sigma HSM, etc) will AF on those three.
~Y
Hmm, interesting. Didn't realize that about those bodies. Dang, that's a bummer.

Tokina 12 -24 f4 is a good compromise for about $450 and it is about $400 less than the Nikkor lens. It is for a DX body and has AF (make sure AF works with a D40) and good glass so that helps justify for your D body.
I have had mine for a couple years a think it a great purchase for a wide-angle that is not a fish-eye.
Play with all of them if you can and read reviews... if you have time.

I have read good things about the Tokina 11-16mm f2.8 - not available quite yet for Nikon but hopefully very soon. I am seriously considering this lens. And probably about 1/3rd the price of Mark's fine lens recomendation.
Well these were in stock at B&H *VERY BRIEFLY* this morning (Thanks for the tip Ed!) before selling out. I ordered one- but was also surprised to see the note they will not focus with the D40/D60 series Nikons. So is probably not the best option for you unfortunately.
Well these were in stock at B&H *VERY BRIEFLY* this morning (Thanks for the tip Ed!) before selling out. I ordered one- but was also surprised to see the note they will not focus with the D40/D60 series Nikons. So is probably not the best option for you unfortunately.
Wow, that sounds like a great lens! any idea on the price point?
This is one of the reasons why if you don't want to spend the money for the higher end bodies you should consider a D50 or a D70s both can be had for about the same or less than a D40.
I'm surprised that Tokina hasn't made their new lenses for Nikon with the in lens motor. Canon has had motor driven lenses for years now. They also don't have a big selection of lenses.