Our first trip (just dh and I), we booked what we could afford and stayed CBR (this was before the values were built).
Next trip, with two kids in tow, we stayed value, again for budget reasons. We felt REALLY cramped and found the buses crowed all the time and decided that we'd have to do a moderate in the future. Keep in mind that at this point we knew nothing about codes and discounts and just went to the
travel agent and booked.
Third trip, I booked POFQ online. Then I found this site, where I learned the POFQ was closed for rehab and guests had been reassigned, BUT if I called WDW, I could probably upgrade for an astonishing low rate. I called. Got the Poly for $25 more a night than I was paying for POFQ. We were hooked, hooked I tell you on the deluxes. We just felt pampered our whole stay.
Fourth trip, dh had a conference in Orlando. If I could get a rate close to the rate offered by the conference hotel, dh's employer would pay for the room. By then I knew about Disboards and Mousesavers. We found a code and could get standard view rooms at AKL or WL for LESS than the conference hotel. Jumped on that one. We stayed at AKL because dh isn't into the whole lodge thing. Kids were unimpressed with the pool
This time, we're staying Yacht CLub. The rest of the family loves Epcot, and we're right there. Kids are still into swimming and we do go back to the resort every day for pool time. Figured we could do YC and skip the water park option on the tickets. Couldn't find a code or discount (other than
AAA) for the trip, so we're shortening the stay (3 nights Disney, 3 nights Cocoa Beach), but it's worth it to us the "feel" of the deluxe resort.