Weeellll, here's your answer.
It is being called "unintentionally laughable" and "unwatchable" . . .
Crossing Over into unintentional hilarity
Clumsy Crash/Babel hybrid will have you choking back chuckles
REVIEW
By Alonso Duralde
Film critic
msnbc.com contributor
updated 3:57 p.m. CT, Tues., Feb. 24, 2009
Alonso Duralde
Film critic
With immigration remaining a constant subject in the news and the punditocracy, you cant accuse the new drama Crossing Over of neglecting the zeitgeist. Theres so much you can accuse it of, however, from a disastrous script to erratic performances to a general air of sanctimony that all combine to make the movie laughable when it isnt flat-out unwatchable.
Writer-director Wayne Kramer whos previously given us the competent The Cooler and the flat-out-bonkers Running Scared follows the templates of Crash and Babel to the letter, from the interweaving plotlines to the polyglot confrontations to the helicopter shots of traffic coursing its way through a chaotic and unfeeling world.
And if you thought Crash and Babel were preachy and awful, you aint seen nothing yet.
Harrison Ford stars as Max Brogan, an Immigration and Customs Enforcement officer whos reasonably compassionate compared to many of his compadres. (He cares, dammit!) On a sweatshop raid, a young illegal laborer (Alice Braga) begs Max to pick up her son from a nearby babysitter. He ignores her plea until that night when, kept awake by his conscience, he returns to the scene and recovers the scrap of paper she gave him with the address.
Meanwhile, young lovers Gavin (Jim Sturgess) and Claire (Alice Eve) are trying desperately to stay in the country. Hes a British-born musician who tries to fake being an Orthodox Jew to get a visa, even though he hasnt been to temple since his bar mitzvah. Shes an Aussie who just got a TV gig and is willing to do anything even participate in an icky affair with immigration honcho Cole (Ray Liotta) to get a green card. (And if you thought the shot of a woman crying in the shower after unwillingly having sex was too much of a cliché to ever again be used in movies, youve thought about this more than Kramer has.)
Coles wife Denise (Ashley Judd), in the meantime, is considering adopting an orphaned African girl whose mother is dying of AIDS. And then theres Maxs Persian partner Hamid (Cliff Curtis), whose sister may have been the victim of an honor killing, and the Korean gangbanger (Justin Chon) who holds up a convenience store the night before his family are to become naturalized citizens, and the Muslim high-schooler (Summer Bishil of Towelhead) who attracts the attention of Homeland Security for writing a school essay in which she attempts to understand the motivations of the 9/11 hijackers.
Trust me, this all sounds way more interesting on paper than how it plays out on screen. Subtlety is constantly forfeited for big, obvious moments that might or might not make any sense whatsoever, to the point where pretty much everyone in the press screening I attended burst out laughing at some inappropriate point. (The films worst culprit in this regard involves a long conversation about immigration and the privileges of citizenship between Hamid and the Korean teen in the middle of the holdup-slash-shootout. I cant begin to do it justice, but its the funniest thing Ive seen on screen all year.)
It also doesnt help when the script fails to do things like establish who Max is and how he normally behaves is his rescue of the womans child out of the ordinary, or does he do this sort of thing every week?
Crossing Over is one of those movies that reminds you how limiting opportunities are for actors of color in Hollywood Im sure the talented Bishil and all of the Middle Eastern and Asian actors in the film are grateful to be working, but theyd probably love a crack at a movie that didnt involve some white filmmakers guilty hand-wringing about race in America. They deserve an equal shot at starring in Bride Wars.