I don't feel bad I was just curious as to what others think of budgetting.
I am just fascinated by the responses and enjoy reading them. Thank you to everyone who has responded.
I don't feel bad for budgetting or saving, it has served my family well. I just get a little confused by some of the posts in the BB and this thread is helping me to see all the differnet perspectives.
I think our idea of a cushion is much different than everyone elses which often makes me feel like the odd man out when people talk about spending and saving.
Dh and I worked hard stuffing those cushions and both of our names are on every single one.
I agree with you. It all boils down to your comfort level. Often you will see posts where people have budgeted down to the penny what a trip will cost, and there is NO margin for error. Or, when they are depending on a check that will be direct-deposited WHILE they are at WDW to cover their bill at checkout. I just couldn't live that way...I'd be in a constant state of panic.
I didn't mean that all mine and DH money was completely separate...we're both on ALL the accounts, we just generally leave the others' accounts alone. I don't spend out of his, he doesn't spend out of mine, etc. It's all fluid and it works out...I don't fuss because he ate out three days for lunch last week and he doesn't ask me why I went to Target twice in the last week. But, we still kind of keep up with the other's balance, and know how much each other's bills are. For example, he pays all the car/house/life insurance every 6 months. But every month, I transfer an amount equal to what he pays for my car and life insurance into his checking account. He's better at saving up to pay BIG bills once a year like property taxes, etc, whereas I do better paying things on a monthly basis like utilities, phone, stuff like that.
I have enjoyed reading the others' responses as well. I am well aware things might change once we have the baby and I'm cutting my work back. But again...that is something that we pseudo-budgeted for. Each payday, I have transfers taken directly out of my check into four different savings accounts. We have our joint savings that is our "big" savings account, and we both have our own smaller 'spend it however you want to' savings accounts. Mine usually goes to vacation, DH tends to buy electronics. I have been putting money into a 'take off work and have a baby account' for a couple of years. I didn't even entertain the notion of getting pregnant until I had at least 6 months of replacement income cushion. I'm probably only going to take 3-4 months off, so whatever is left is going to roll into the baby's account, which my parents and DH's parents are also automatically contributing to.
SO...I guess we DO budget in a way, but it's more a matter of budgeting so that we have a lot of savings as opposed to budgeting how we spend our income.