Any color, stale. I hear they are also especially good roasted. I tried the "chocolate flovoured" ones at Halloween, they were very light on the chocolate, and they were not sugar coated.
HHHMMMM...chocolate covered Peeps! that sounds like a possibiltity..but only is the sugar is under the chocolate too! But smores...no way.
I like my Peeps stale...usually by day 2. I think the white or purple are my favorites. I don't buy the blue they turn my mouth blue. And I buy the chicks because you get more in the package.
of course if you get the bunnies you have to eat the ears first.