I see they just posted a disney dining show video giving pretty good reviews for this place. I have to say that while I may be an outlier based on what practically everyone else has said, I was there 2 nights ago for dinner, took 1 bite of each type of meat, and asked the server to take it away. I wonder if they make ALL the food around lunch time and keep it warm through dinner. I don't know - perhaps I had temporary covid for that one hour or something - but I thought it was horrendous. Nothing was worth eating. The vegetables were fine - buttered, canned corn and briefly grilled/steamed green beans were ok, and the mashed potatoes were good enough if you like a pound of butter per bite. I also casually asked my dining neighbors (at the tables adjacent to mine) what they thought and they all agreed with me, at least to the point of being disappointed or saying it had gone downhill.
Also, unless you are under 5'1" and weigh less than 100 lbs, ask to NOT SIT ON THE BACK "patio" area. Those tiny wooden kid's tables are absolutely ridiculous. What are they thinking?? Everything else in that entire resort is amazing, and sure they look cute, but c'mon man! You can tell everyone back there was eating at an angle with one leg shifted to the side, because they're kid's tables! Ridiculous.
I will say I enjoyed the breakfast a lot (other than the mickey waffles which they're using up their "wrong" batter from early reopening days; I posted a separate thread on that), and the entire staff including servers are excellent. The server I had for the bad dinner gave me zero grief at all, took it away and took care of everything. I had to run and grab some cash and return so I could at least give her a cash tip because she's not responsible for the food being bad.
I've had disney BBQ plenty of times before. I'm certainly not comparing to Fat Matt's or Daddy D'z (my 2 favorites) but it's always been fairly good to me, nonetheless. This was not my experience this time.