Personally I wouldn't pay attention to what anyone says about a restaurant. With so many people and opinions you'll never get a 100% agreement about a restaurant. I've been to some that everyone said was great(Le' Cellier) and I found the experience to be ok, and to some that said it was lousy(O'Hana) and loved it.
The only opinion I would take here about a restaurant being lousy is ABC Commissary. Trust me that one is horrible. There may be the occassional one or two who like it but the overwhelming majority have found it to be aweful.