Which would you choose?

[TPCShauna]

Here's some background. DH and I booked AKL Concierge and decided we didn't like that it was so far away from everything so we changed our ressie to YC Concierge but then didn't like that the lounge had limited hours so changed to a BWI Garden Suite. Of course, now that we have it, DH is moaning that he's not sure it's what he wants and he thinks BWI Concierge Deluxe might be better.

Here's what we want in a room:
King bed
Quiet!!!
Area (preferably outside) where we can smoke
Space so we don't want to kill each other from spending too much time together
Some kind of view

My question is which would you choose: BWI Garden Suite, Concierge Deluxe or Concierge and why is that your choice?

We are traveling 12/17 - 12/23 of this year. TIA for your assistance!

 

[Leota]

Since none of your listed wants includes the amenities of a concierge room, I'd use the extra money on getting a more spacious room. It sounds like that's what you really place a high priority on. I'd go with a garden suite or a one bedroom villa.

 

[Eeyore1928]

We stayed in a Con. room with a water view and tal about noisy!! We were directly on top of ESPN and all we heard was that stupid jingle. I don't care if I ever watch sportscenter again!!

Personally the garden suites are nice..but I would opted for the Yacht Club with a view of the boardwalk! Very quiet....nice resort....large rooms...and a short walk to the boardwalk!

 

[Avalanche]

If the only reason you switched was because of location I would go back to AK. It may look far, but it's closer to MGM and Epcot then you would think. BW shares transportation with YC/BC and S/D, so might be closer but will take almost as long since BW is the first to pick up and last to drop off. AK is quiet and has great views. BW is far from quiet. Dining choices are great especially if you don't have picky kids to please.