Which would you choose?

[MJMcBride]

I'm going with the Bistro here. Its quality.

 

[PlutoLuvr]

I voted for Bistro

Kathy, really good, quality seafood places are a dime a dozen where you and I live. That's what I thought about when I scratched Narcoosses off my own list.

Raglan Road can be very loud, and the reviews are also hit or miss.

I can't comment on the Italian place. I'm Italian myself and going out and paying for Italian that never measures up to my own family's cooking seems very wasteful to me.

I also haven't been to Yachtsman, but a steak is a steak is a steak, yanno? Again, not a very "unique" Disney experience ... IMHO. YMMV.

So that leaves me with Bistro. You will have an extremely unique experience at Bistro. The menu isn't homogenized as some are saying most of the WDW restaurants now are. The prices are also in line with non-Disney restaurants in this category off property.

We're also picking our ressies for our fall trip. Funny, we like a creative menu and a kitchen where the chef is still in charge. Hence, we are leaning towards restaurants that do not accept the DDP. So far, we're doing V&A, Bistro & I'm asking about Wolfgang Puck's upstairs dining cafe.

Have fun and hope you're doing well!!!

 

[Karnak]

Had you set up the poll to let the one NOT to visit of the five be voted on, it would have worked. And I would have picked Ragland Road. Very poor food.

Karnak.

 

[TigerKat]

Had you set up the poll to let the one NOT to visit of the five be voted on, it would have worked. And I would have picked Ragland Road. Very poor food.

Karnak.

I don't have enough common sense to think that way!

 

[Hopefully]

I would pick the following:

Tutto Italia
Narcoossees
Ragland Road
Bistro De Paris

I left off Yachtsman Steakhouse. It is one of only 2 restaurants in WDW we will NOT return to (The other is H & V in DHS). We, 3 adults, all had a horrible meal there last year. The setting is beautiful and the service was great but the food was terrible.
I haven't tried Tutto Italia yet, but it has gotten good reviews. I though Narcoosses was great when I ate there a few years ago.
We loved Ragland Road. Yes it was loud, but we had made late ADR's in order to hear the band and see the Step Dancer. Our food was good, service was fine and we had a fun evening.
I have not been to Bistro De Paris either. DH does not like French cooking so it is unlikely we will eat there.
Have a Great Trip

 

[TigerKat]

bumping

 

[Karnak]

I don't have enough common sense to think that way!

 

[wezee]

I would omit Tutto Italia, I have looked at the menu several times and it just doesn't appeal to DH or I. We love Narcoosees ( a must every trip).

 

[TigerKat]

Thanks everyone I'm pretty sure we're going with:

Bistro
Yachtsman
Narcoossee's
Raglan Road (This one for the overall experience, not just the food)

 

[Poppinsme]

Thanks everyone I'm pretty sure we're going with:

Bistro
Yachtsman
Narcoossee's
Raglan Road (This one for the overall experience, not just the food)

Great choices!!!

Because of you we are going to Flying Fish.

 

[TigerKat]

Great choices!!!

Because of you we are going to Flying Fish.

I hope you enjoy it!!!!!!

 

[Disney Ron]

Hi Kathy,

Anywhere we don't have to cook works for me!

Out of your list the only one we are going to on our upcoming trip is Ragland Road...can you say, CHEERS!

Ann

 

[TigerKat]

Hi Kathy,

Anywhere we don't have to cook works for me!

Out of your list the only one we are going to on our upcoming trip is Ragland Road...can you say, CHEERS!

Ann

CHEERS Ann!!