We did December 2010 at AKV. We're glad we did as we wouldn't have otherwise made it over there.
For December of 2012, we're doing a split stay at BWV - BLT - BWV. We're doing weekends at BWV and weekdays at BLT givent he point premiums. I don't usually advocate for theme park view as I think it's a waste of points. We loved our standard view this past October. Could stand on the balcony and see the castle.
However, for Christmas, we wanted to be able to just look out our windows of the living room and enjoy the view. Special time of year and with the pending point reallocation, we may not get this chance again. We're only doing it because it is the lowest point time right now.
We like resorts that actually celebrate the holidays in some unique way. Our dining reservations made it easier for us to get to othe resorts. We really liked: 1) AKV, great tree 2) WLV, again - great tree 3) BLT, love the outdoor Mickey wreath. We didn't get to any of the other
DVC resorts in 2010. In 2012 we'll get to BWV for sure and hopefully over to BCV.
As for all resorts, I really liked GF the most and was most disappointed by the Poly.
Good luck! We'll be there 11/30-12/9. Can't wait. Can't believe it's still 11 months away. This will be a 14 month gap between World visits. That will be our longest since July 2007 to February 2009. We're definitely spoiled.