Places to which I would return:
California Grill-Contemporary
The Yachtsman Steakhouse-Yacht Club
Cape May character breakfast-Beach Club
Boma (dinner, haven't tried breakfast)-AKL
Big River Grill-Boardwalk
I wouldn't go back to Captain's Grill at YC, either. After one great meal there in 2005, we've had two less than stellar experiences since. One involved produce stickers still on the apple slices in our sandwiches, and the other involved raw meat on a salad. There are enough other options, especially with Epcot within walking distance, that it's pretty easy to cross this one off the list.