Which Italian-style TS for DINNER?

[Quin]

Which would you choose? No little kids involved - everybody will be eating off the adult menu. Characters are irrelevant. Location is irrelevant - this is early pre-planning. Want a TS dinner, not lunch.

I haven't included the new restaurant in Epcot Italy because we just don't know enough about it yet. Would like your opinion between the 3 known places: Mama Melrose in HS, Tony's in MK, or Tutto Italia in Epcot. We would only do 1 Italian restaurant - which would you choose and why?

 

[OhioMom]

I chose Tutto Italia. We have eaten there once and at Tony's twice. I cannot comment on Mama's. I thought the food at Tutto was much better than Tony's, although the price is higher as well. Although I like the Lady & the Tramp theme of Tony's, Tutto is a very pretty place and I remember being impressed by it. It seems like an "authentic" italian restaurant...take that for what it's worth since I'm not italian and have never been to Italy, lol. I enjoyed the complimentary olives and the cute waiters!

 

[Tiffany]

Which would you choose? No little kids involved - everybody will be eating off the adult menu. Characters are irrelevant. Location is irrelevant - this is early pre-planning. Want a TS dinner, not lunch.

I haven't included the new restaurant in Epcot Italy because we just don't know enough about it yet. Would like your opinion between the 3 known places: Mama Melrose in HS, Tony's in MK, or Tutto Italia in Epcot. We would only do 1 Italian restaurant - which would you choose and why?

Out of the three you listed I voted for Mama Melrose's at DHS. We enjoy the dining experiance here the best out of the three you listed.

Now if you are looking for the best Italian dining on property then Il Mulino's at the WDW Swan is the best. It is NOT on the DDP but you can get the TIW discount here.

 

[disneygymmom]

Without a doubt TUTTO ITALIA!!!!! It is our fav disney resturaunt by far.We talk about it alot even once were home.Be there in three weeks!!! Cant wait!!!!

 

[a1tinkfans]

we're deciding too.............

 

[webray]

If you want to eat in a park, then Tutto. If you want a really wonderful Italian meal then head over to the Swan and eat at IL Mulino.

 

[Vickie1016]

Tutto Italia, hands down. Best Italian food on site.

 

[B-Ride]

I voted for Tutto Italia even though we have never eaten there. We will be visiting for the first time this August so I hope I am right.

We enjoyed our meal at Mama Melrose a few years ago but it wasn't spectacular enough to become a must do for us.

 

[chocovrdmicears]

We have eaten at all three.

First choice: Tutto. (if you are on the dining plan or don't mind cost.) We have eaten here several times and enjoyed all of our meals. The food is definately more *authentic* Italian than the other 2 choices. The service is excellent and the desserts are yummy.

Second choice: Mama Melrose. Decent Italian. Sometimes very good, sometimes average. We have never had a bad experience here, but it isn't a place that we *must* come back to every trip.

Last choice: Tony's. Had my birthday dinner there last June and it was terrible. The food was really bad and the service was even worse.

 

[Boardwalk Tigger]

I would head over to the Dolphin.

 

[DisMN]

I would head over to the Dolphin.

Me too.

 

[SophiasDad]

Definitely Tutto!

 

[Leota]

I would head over to the SWAN - for Il Mulino. It's fabulous.

 

[NatashaDisneyCM]

I would head over to the SWAN - for Il Mulino. It's fabulous.

I asked this question a few months ago...and this is the place that came up #1!

 

[madalex]

now if you are looking for the best italian dining on property then il mulino's at the wdw swan is the best. It is not on the ddp but you can get the tiw discount here.

+1

 

[Silver Queen]

We would go to Il Mulino at the Swan.

 

[Pakey]

Il Mulino.

 

[princessallegra]

Tutto for sure. We've eaten there twice and had great meals each time. We love eating outside and wait for an outside table, we just love the ambiance out there. We found the food to be authentic and delicious. We love the antipasto for 2 sooo good.