Which Italian Restuarant?

[Spoogle]

I'm trying to make my ADR's and wanted to know which was the better Italian restaurant - Mama Melrose, Tutto Italia or Tony's Town Square?

 

[honeydiane1953]

I would try the new one at Epcot. I have eaten at the ones mentioned and OMG never again. Via Napolia

 

[Satchmo128]

I would try the new one at Epcot. I have eaten at the ones mentioned and OMG never again. Via Napolia

I haven't eaten at any of the three mentioned, but I would also suggest trying the Via Napoli in Epcot. The pizza's look AMAZING.

 

[BrcsDisneyPrncs]

Others may not agree - but we opted to eat at Tony's the last day of our recent anniversary trip. It was terrible! (this coming from a girl who grew up on canned sauce and now just uses crushed tomatoes on her spaghetti). The pasta was so overcooked and gummy, the tostada thing that came with it almost cracked a tooth, and the sauce tasted like nothing!

I was very disappointed. However I'm sure others have had good experiences.

As others on this thread have said, we are going to try to get a reservation at Via Napoli for September, the menu sounds delicious!

 

[purple figment]

I've been to all three and would definitely go back to Tutto's again. Excellent dinner, excellent service.

We're planning to try Via Napoli on our next trip. We've been to their sister restaurant, Naples, in DTD Disneyland so we're looking forward to comparing them.

 

[PinkEars]

I would try the new one at Epcot. I have eaten at the ones mentioned and OMG never again. Via Napolia

By the sounds of it you wont like the new italian restaurant either

 

[Kim&Chris]

We thought Tutto Italia was actually very good!!! It's on our 'itinerary' for this fall!!

 

[disneymath]

We've eaten at TI and really really enjoyed our meals. More upscale atmosphere than some WDW park restaurants.
We're going to try MM this trip with the F! Dining Package - the menu sounds good.
Honestly, the menu at TT does not appeal to me.

 

[PoohsFan1]

We have eaten at Mama Melrose and Tony's Town Square before and liked both of them a lot. We are going back to Tony's in September. We are also trying out Tutto Italia for the first time in September as well and are excited to be doing so.

 

[mom2travel]

We have eaten at all 3. Tony's was quite awhile ago though - we didn't have any complaints about the food. The portions were huge though; I remember us saying we would share if we go back.

Mama Melrose - we always enjoy the food here (have been w/ a large group also, and no one complained about their meal)

Tutto Italia - tried this for the first time last year. All 4 of us enjoyed our meals. I think it was more expensive than the others though

Personally, I would go with whichever is in the park we would want to be in that day/night

 

[stormer]

It depends on what you are used to and looking for. We eat at Tony's and Mama Melrose, but don't consider either to be real Italian food. Tutto's food is much more "Italian"

 

[DisneyJen0504]

Try Tuttos.
Mama Melrose is not just bad Italian food, it is bad food. Ugh. Never again! We gave it a second chance on our last trip and all of us had terrible food and service.

 

[honeydiane1953]

By the sounds of it you wont like the new italian restaurant either

I may not but the other three were terrible. I will try the Via one though.

 

[SGMCO]

We ate at Tutto last trip and it was our best meal all week.
I have ADRs for next month for Tutto again.
Plus we always eat at Tony's at MK--my DS favorite.
If you're on the DP it's nice to try different places and not worry about cost.
I don't think I would eat at Tuttos if I had to pay OOP--it's expensive.

 

[DCTooTall]

Doh... sorry...

 

[ROEDISNEY]

Tutto Italia
Tony's
MM
Via Napoli just open so can't speak yet

 

[RescueRanger]

We just ate at Tony's last week. One word....YUCK!. Never again! We are going to try Tutto's for our Thanksgiving trip (hopefully our CP meal).