I had this same question a few months ago! We went for our 1 yr anniversary (we also spent our honeymoon in WDW!). We took my little sister and my step daughter. We picked Ragland Road and were not sorry at all!!! It was great!!! It was the best meal of both our trips!! It was also great to walk through PI afterwards, we aren't really club people, but we got a drink at one of the stands and just kinda walked through and made a trip through the west side. Anyway, it really was great. We had the serious sirloin and both girls had the paddy's pork. For dessert the best in my opinion was the bread pudding. Enjoy!!