Which is better HDDR or Spirit of ALoha??

[hthrbells]

Thanks I was going to post the same question except my DS's are going to be three and five.

 

[Clotho]

If you want the truest deatils, you need to go to AllEars Reviews:

Hoop Dee Doo Revue
Average rating: 8.89 out of 10
96% of reviewers recommend it to others
The *entire first page* of reviews is 9's and 10's out of 10, positive and GLOWING! (Even the second page only goes so low as rating it 7!)
Comments like:
"This was an AWESOME experience!"
"This was our favorite meal at Disney!!"
"Go see this show, you will NOT be disappointed."
"I cannot say enough good things about this show."
"It's corny, but in the BEST way!"
"Food was great, show was better. "
"I am sure whenever we go back to WDW, we will be sure to go again."
"(We) were a little skeptical about how we would like it. It was hands down our favorite thing about our trip. "

Spirit of Aloha
Average Review 7 out of 10
72% recommend it to others
8 of the 15 reviews on the first page are below 5's, with some as low as 2!
Comments include
"The show was super-hokey. Annoying at times. My kids looked like they were being tortured. So we left."
"Save Your Money!"
"The only thing worse than the corny show was the service."
" It's too expensive to sit and listen to a mediocre dinner show."
"The comedy and banter is terrible and not funny."
"We will not go again. I would choose a regular dinner or find another show to try. Very disappointed."

And of course:
"Overall, I still can't believe the quality of the food and service here. You might not know it from this review, but I am usually a very easy person to please. This was nothing that I expected from my favorite place in the world. Go to the Hoop-dee-Doo which never disappoints, not this."


We read these same disparaging reviews of Spirit of Aloha, but we thought it couldn't POSSIBLY be as bad as those reviews. And anyway, there were still some GOOD reviews, so there has to be some redeeming qualities... But now. We are now among the "incredibly disappointed, never go again, never recommend" crowd.

Read for yourself!
http://land.allears.net/reviewpost/showcat.php?cat=37