We chose BCV because, well....we ADORE it!!
For us, it is the perfect resort....the villas wing is quiet and serene (actually the whole resort seems serene to us), but you are within minutes of some great action!!
Stormalong Bay is an AMAZING pool complex. I think this pool has something for everyone of all ages. My dd has been playing in the shallow, sand-bottom section since she was 2. We could sit her in the water, and she would build sandcastles for hours. Now, she ventures over to other sections, but still loves the sandcastle area.
The food choices at BCV are plentiful. Beaches 'n Cream is one of our favorite places to eat, but it is really nice to have Hurricane Hanna's for the days that you are out by the pool. Sometimes, when the wait for B&C is out of control, we often get food from Hanna's (and dh gets an "adult beverage") and just sit and listen to the waterfalls at SAB. However, there are other great food choices at BCV as well. The salads in the Marketplace are REALLY good, and the gelato is a must do. The desserts are rich and heavenly. Speaking of desserts, the work out room at BCV is nice, conveniently located, and has another great view of SAB. There is also Cape May's which has a great character breakfast, and Yachtsman's Steakhouse for fine dining with yet another great view!!! We also love just to be able to sit in a lounge chair by the lake and stick our feet in the sand, while our dd feeds the ducks. This is also a great place to watch Illuminations from a distance...it is the perfect end to a heavenly day!!!
However, there are other things we love about BCV. It is nice to know that if we ever need it, BCV has the Sandcastle Club for our daughter (or, more importantly...for us). We love the architecture of this resort...it is just breathtaking. We love feeding the turtles and ducks from our balcony when we get a canal room. We love the casual, yet elegant feel to the resort. We LOVE, LOVE, LOVE being so close to Epcot. The world showcase is one of my favorite places on the face of the Earth...so, having a semi-private entrance right into this section of the park is wonderful. We like to travel off-season when most of the parks close early. This is great because the World Showcase is always open until at least nine, so whatever park we go to during the day (except for MK days because this park stays open late as well), we always finish our day at Epcot. We either watch Illuminations from within the park, or sitting on the beach. It has become a "tradition" for us. My dd is now 5, and we are having a difficult time planning to go in the off-season this year. We have a trip planned for March, but we were hoping to get a winter trip in as well. I asked my dd tonight if we could get rooms somewhere else besides BCV, would she want to go, and she replied, "No way....I'd rather not go Mom." Well....she just may get her wish, but that pretty much sums up our level of devotion to this resort.
I hope that you do a lot of thinking about what makes that "special place" for you, and I hope that you buy at that resort. I think the advice of staying at, or at least visiting all resorts before you buy is important. We bought sight unseen at 3 different resorts because I thought I knew what I wanted. None of those resorts were BCV. After we visited, we sold our points and bought at BCV...and we lost some money in the process. But, what is more valuable to us than our money is dh's vacation time. It was very important to us that we get to spend those precious few weeks at BCV, and therefore we felt we needed to own there. I hope you do not make the same mistakes we did.
Good luck!!!