Which do you prefer??? MVMCP or MNSSHP?

[Laurafoster]

Ive been to both several times but im now looking at booking for next year!!

Just wondered which evet people preferred?

 

[Cyrano]

Would love to hear why people prefer one over the other

 

[KayleeUK]

I have done both. MNSSHP quite a few times and MVMCP for the first time last year.

How can you choose?? We were lucky enough last year that during our trip we were able to go to both!! We planning to go at the same time next year to do both!

MNSSHP - We dress up, there are some great character's about all dressed for Halloween. I love the parade and fireworks.

MVMCP - Loved the show and parade Again great character interaction. Loved the snow on main street and cookie and hot chocolate.

 

[jockey]

We attended MNSSHP back in 2004 and loved it, lots of people were dressed up and we had fun filling our treat bags!

This year we attended MVMCP and although we really enjoyed it we found MNSSHP had more of an atmosphere. It rained the night we went to MVMCP all night so there was no snow on main street! We had an ADR for Cp the night of MVMCP and it was great!

I would attend both again as they are great but if I had to make a choice it would be MNSSHP!

 

[Minniespal]

I've been to MNSSHP several times and hoping to go to MVMCP for the first time this year.

Laura ~ Have you tried HHN at Universal?

 

[tashasmum]

I prefer MNSSHP as the atmosphere was much better. Nearly everybody dresses up in some kind of way but not so much as the kids get frightened.MVMCP is a nice one to do when you can get your head around the idea that although it is 80 degrees outside christmas is just around the corner.

 

[UKDEB]

Like a lot of things, I think it can depend on the way circumstances conspire to create a particular experience on any given day. For example, I've seen IllumiNations scores of times - some have been outstanding moments that will endure for a lifetime, others less so.

I've done MVMCP and MNSSHP once each. When we did MVMCP back in 2001, I thoroughly enjoyed it. When we attended MNSSHP with the same group of family and friends in 2002, I came away feeling it was just an excuse to extract more money for the privilege of being in a (very crowded) Magic Kingdom during the evening. It didn't help that our adult friends were determined to stand in every 'Trick or Treat' line, no matter how long, to make sure they got their money's worth of penny sweets (that they were never going to eat anyway) . Even the kids weren't bothered after the first couple. As the parade ended (at around 10.20pm, from memory) and we strolled into Tomorrowland, the skies opened and we had the most rain we've ever seen in all our visits there. We sheltered under the canopy of The Lunching Pad and waited. And waited. And waited. All the time the rain just got worse and worse. Eventually, at midnight, Matt ran across to the nearest shop and bought umbrellas (all the ponchos were gone). We were all wearing brand new trainers, so we took them off and stumbled, barefoot and ankle deep in water (literally), to the exit. By the time we got to the car at the TTC, we were all soaked to the bone (we soon gave up with the umbrellas). No wonder that I don't have very good memories of MNSSHP! Oh, and we almost got wiped out by the Headless Horseman as he swooped around the bend (that little gem has just come back to me).

I don't think I'd rush back to either, but neither would I rule them out. I do think everyone should experience both at least once.

 

[Strommie]

I have only done MVMCP, but would love to try MNSSHP and also HHN Need to persuade DBF to go back this year

 

[ely3857]

I havnt done either but at Pop last year I felt we were missing out on something. Lot's a Halloween decorations & merchandise around and loads of people dressed up waiting to go to MK

It really did seem like fun and Me & Dominique have decided we will go in 2008, even if we cant drag Gavin and Dan we will take the girls and have fun!



Jodie

 

[jns]

only done the Halloween party which was great

Great poll

 

[squitty]

Tough one....I liked them both for different reasons.
MNSSHP- Great for dressing up - great parade - Hallowishes - Candy Stations.
MVMCP- Great atmosphere - snow on main st - great parade - Holidaywishes - walking round in warmth listening to Christmas music.

Will be doing MNSSHP again this year.

Having done MVCMP more times than MNSSHP I would have to choose MVMCP.