Another vote for HDDR!! We've done both. Dd, 11, loves HDDR. The show is good and quite funny. The Luau show is okay but not one I would do more than once. The food at both is nothing to write home about tho. The food is more to my likeing at HDDR. My family doesn't do ribs, so that's a problem for us. But we loved the bread. Yum. Don't get me started on that strawberry shortcake. Dh and I each took one bite and said...'nope, not eating this!!' Bring me Jell-O if you have to but not that stuff. We plan on doing HDDR again.