We chose Storytellers for us. Frankly, having a kid named Dale makes a big difference in which characters are important for us to see.

Princesses need not apply for this family!
We chose a 7:00 am seating on a Wednesday, when the park opened (without EE) at 9:00. When we were seated, there were only about 5 families in the restaurant with us. In the 40 minutes we were there, we were visited by and had terrific interaction with: Dale (thank goodness if we had to have only one chipmunk, it was him! He's got the red/brown nose, FYI.), Meeko, Terk, Ranger Dave (a regular CM dressed like a park ranger, but a nice interaction, nonetheless), Koda and Kenai. Not a hairless character in sight, but we aren't exactly a Princess family, so it worked fine for us.
We chose buffet, but only because I'm lazy and wanted a little of everything. The buffet choices were EXCELLENT! Plenty of ripe, fresh, beautiful fruit (strawberries, melon, whole apples and bananas), scrambled eggs, casing sausage links, MONSTROUS bacon, several potato dishes (a California thing? We don't do potatoes like that in Texas!), eggs Benedict, and a beautiful made-to-order omelette station. Pancakes and Mickey waffles are included, but you have to ask for them.
Maybe it was timing, maybe it was location, maybe it was Magic, but we had a marvelous meal at Storytellers and will definitely plan another meal there next trip.