Which cake topper do you like better?

[minniebride]

I know it sounds trivial because they are similar, but I'm being very indecisive!

#1: Disney

#2: Lenox

 

[camara381]

I prefer #2 only because it looks more elegant.

 

[MegKate]

ITA with Carolina - much more elegant.

 

[Pirate's Princess]

What are some of your other wedding ideas or favorite characters? I'm not a fan of the polka dots in the first one, but the second is very formal.

 

[minniebride]

What are some of your other wedding ideas or favorite characters? I'm not a fan of the polka dots in the first one, but the second is very formal.

Thank you! Well, we are still in the early planning phases (newly engaged!), but our song is going to be the theme song from Beauty & the Beast ("tale as old as time..."). We might do something with Beauty & the Beast for our invitations as well, but I'm not a big fan of them for our cake topper.

At first I really liked the Disney topper (thought the Lenox was too plain), but I was thinking the Lenox one might be a special memento to display in our china cabinet afterwards. I haven't come across any other ideas though & I definitely want to stick with a Disney cake topper theme.

 

[Bride-to-be]

I like the first one - just because its more colorful and more mickeyish.

Honestly if you aren't over the top in love with either of them then I would keep looking until you see something you instantly fall for.

 

[lpizzuro123]

The day we picked up my ring, we went to the WOD store on 5th Avenue in NYC. We purchased the Disney one (#1) for our wedding topper. After we were engaged for a while, friends gave us the Lenox one (#2). I really wanted to use the Disney one and did not want the Lenox one to break traveling down to Florida so we went with the Disney one. As an added FYI, the Disney one is more white and the Lenox one is more cream colored. Not that that makes a huge difference but just as an FYI.

Here is a photo of the Disney one on our cake on our wedding day. Also, both are in our china cabinet with out wedding stuff.

I have a better close up but it is not uploaded on my computer at the moment.

Linda

 

[S <3 M]

I like the second one better. It's more romantic

 

[Sarah <3 Disney]

I voted for number two, but have always been a fan of the Precious Moments Disney Collection:

http://www.preciousmoments.com/content.cfm/product/Magically-Ever-After

They have a couple Beauty and the Beast pieces too. Here's a link to their Disney Collection:
http://www.preciousmoments.com/cont...me&utm_medium=Text&utm_campaign=Disney&vall=1

Beauty and the Beat specific:
http://www.preciousmoments.com/content.cfm/product/Follow-Your-Heart-Belle
http://www.preciousmoments.com/content.cfm/product/It-Is-In-The-Giving-That-We-Receive
http://www.preciousmoments.com/content.cfm/product/Friends-Share-Caring-Hearts

 

[CharacterFan]

I like the first, but you could always use both. Our cake table is going to have several cake toppers scattered around it. We're going to have the first one. A Sorcerer Mickey one and a Goofy one. I'd like to also have a Prince Eric/Ariel one (minus Ariel would work) and a Beauty and Beast one, and then dfi wants to add a Lion King one.
Although if we only add Mickey and Goofy. We're going to get big figs, since their our favorite charaters.

 

[tiffster]

i love lenox, so i voted for #2. i think its classy and elegant. i want the snow white for my snow white theme wedding. but too pricey

 

[aftensgirl]

Like the Lenox best.

 

[Bride-to-be]

I like the first, but you could always use both. Our cake table is going to have several cake toppers scattered around it. We're going to have the first one. A Sorcerer Mickey one and a Goofy one. I'd like to also have a Prince Eric/Ariel one (minus Ariel would work) and a Beauty and Beast one, and then dfi wants to add a Lion King one.
Although if we only add Mickey and Goofy. We're going to get big figs, since their our favorite charaters.

That sounds really cool!!!

 

[KennedyMcKenna]

I must say I like the first better just because it seems a bit more festive than the lenox. I'm not a fan of all the same cream color and like the break up of the black tux. Congrats!!!

 

[minniebride]

Thanks guys!! I really appreciate your input

I'm kind of leaning toward the Lenox.

DF is very anti Precious Moments, so that's out-he says the dolls faces creep him out (insert eyeroll here)

I love the idea of a bunch of different cake toppers surrounding the cake!

What does the Snow White topper look like?

Lpizzuro123: I love your cake & the presentation!! Thank you for sharing your pic Where was your reception?

 

[KSchwagg86]

Love the Lenox one!

 

[Handbag Lady]

I picked number 1. It was also MY cake topper!

I like the Lenox one, too, but it would have been too formal for our Goofy's Presents cake we had.