Which Butterbeer is your favorite?

[imprint]

Hot Butterbeer in the morning and either/both Frozen or ice cream in the afternoon.

 

[PaintsWindColors]

Gotta get the ice cream!! Or better yet, pair it with a cold butterbeer!

 

[thegajone]

Haven't tried hot but cold is way better than frozen IMO. Plus cold more resembles what they drink in the movie; for some silly reason that matters to me, lol.

For someone who's never had it and wonders what it tastes like, the best way I can describe it is butterscotch-flavored cream soda. I've heard it's too sweet, and I can understand that opinion, but I much favor savory food over sweet food and I still thought it was pretty good. I'd never be able to drink more than 1 in a single trip though, and even that one takes me about 30-40 minutes to finish of if I drink it by myself.

I'm definitely looking forward to trying the pumpkin drink next time.

 

[macraven]

looking at the poll above, your cold choice is holding strong in second place.
if that many prefer it, it has to be good!

 

[tinydancer09]

Seems the types have grown since this poll! I must say the ice cream takes the cake for me as of right now. I just can't have much of it as ice cream and heavy dairy makes me.. not feel well. Can't wait to try the fudge and potted cream!

 

[macraven]

and which type of butterbeer are you holding in your avatar?

 

[angierae]

I didn't try hot, but I vastly preferred frozen over cold. DD preferred cold.

 

[SA mom]

We really liked the butterbeer fudge.

 

[cbsnyber1]

and which type of butterbeer are you holding in your avatar?

That might not be Butterbeer . . .

 

[Skiton]

I thought hot was wonderful, WAY better than cold. But, it's so rich that I could only have a few sips and even with DH and I sharing one, we threw half of it away. Haven't tried frozen.

 

[macraven]

Wait until you do


Brain freeze if you don't drink it slowly

 

[schumigirl]

Wait until you do


Brain freeze if you don't drink it slowly

Lol......ain't that the truth.........

I found that out first time I drank it.........

 

[Sparkly]

I tried the frozen one- I almost threw up after half a cup! Way, way too sweet.

 

[jollygreen]

I like all of them but hot is the most recent one I've had. It's been over a year since I've had any of the others, so I'll definitely need to refresh my memory in May.

Also, there's butterbeer fudge???

 

[schumigirl]

I like all of them but hot is the most recent one I've had. It's been over a year since I've had any of the others, so I'll definitely need to refresh my memory in May.

Also, there's butterbeer fudge???

That sounds sweet. But I'm not a fudge fan really........

I find the frozen butterbeer the least sweet.......always share a cup each trip with DH.

Yes, refresh your memory is always a good idea.........

 

[SA mom]

I like all of them but hot is the most recent one I've had. It's been over a year since I've had any of the others, so I'll definitely need to refresh my memory in May.

Also, there's butterbeer fudge???

Yes, one of my daughters had to have it. It has the consistency of fudge, but it has two layers and tastes just like butterbeer on the bottom and the foam on top. It was pretty unique. I will also say that this particular daughter prefers savory over sweet...except when it comes to butterbeer. She had it everyday for 5 days and likes the cold one the best.