Which ADR to skip?

[gingerfeathers]

We're heading to WDW Sept. 14-18 for the first part of our honeymoon. I had ADRs set for our first three nights, and then on the last night there we were going to go to the ESPN Club (soon-to-be-DH figures he'll be craving some pub fare by then!).

Well, today I managed to score us a Chef Mickey's ADR for that last night--I just couldn't pass it up! So I'm thinking about maybe cancelling one of our other ADRs to head over to the boardwalk? Or even cancelling CM? But I just don't know what to pass up!

Our ADRs are: LTT, Tony's, Le Cellier, and then CM.

Excluding Le Cellier, which definitely will NOT be going anywhere, which one would you skip, and why? It may be that we don't cancel any, but if there was a night to cancel.. which one?

Thanks in advance!

 

[mickeymotto]

Probably Tonys would get the axe.

 

[Maxamuus]

I would second Tony's. We had it for my trip coming up and canceled it. The reviews spoke loud and clear that you could get better food from Olive Garden. We can go there any night of the week so why bother with Tony's?

 

[misslissa]

I also agree with Tonys.... your other choices are awesome!

 

[JSTX]

I agree. I would take ESPN over Tony's any day. The food at ESPN club is really quite good. I am not a fan of Tony's.

 

[Northern_Julie]

Tony's hands down.

 

[gingerfeathers]

Hmm. I'd say the consensus is clear. Thanks everyone! I think we'll do ESPN Club on day two.

 

[Lynn5700]

I'm going to say Tony's....I axed mine for our October trip and switched to Kona lol...I never hear good things about it on here and I trust my DISers lol.

 

[Leigha]

If I had to cancel one, it would be Tony's as it seems to be nothing special. Why not keep Tony's and go to ESPN for lunch and pay out of pocket? It isn't that expensive.

 

[rcraw45425]

If I had to cancel one, it would be Tony's as it seems to be nothing special. Why not keep Tony's and go to ESPN for lunch and pay out of pocket? It isn't that expensive.

Ditch Tonys! You can get ten times better Italian at Olive Garden and that's saying a lot!

 

[mickeysgirl17]

Tony's or LTT

 

[kimis]

I agree LTT or Tonys.

 

[PEANUT1]

I think Tony's and LTT are equally bad so either one.

 

[SoonipiLady]

But that's only because I want your ressie!!!

Actually, I would cancel Tony's. The food is unpredictable at best!

I wouldn't feel at all bad about missing it, unless your heart is set on eating in the MK that evening. Personally, I don't eat in that park much for dinner since we are wine people and it's not available in the MK.

Karen

 

[leanan]

Tony's is my choice like everyone else. It is not a character experience and it is just Italian food. I had ressies there two years ago and walked out because the menu was too limited and plain for the money as I was paying OoP.

LCs obviously should go nowhere as the soup alone is to die for. OMG. I could not get ressies so I am getting a to go container at the podium hopefully to take out and eat since it is a must have.

 

[MissionMouse]

Another Tony's and this is usually the trend on this site. You might consider Rose & Crown to replace ESPN, unless you are dead set on visiting this chain.

 

[MickeyNicki]

Well...that is tough because LTT menu does not appeal to me and Chef Mickeys was horrible.

I guess I would dump both and try and score something else.