We do the same thing....find ourselves making ADRs for the same restaurant every year. That being said, we did venture out just a bit last trip and ate dinner at a few "new" restaurants.
Chef Mickey's was definitely not what it was hyped up to be. The food was just blah and the restaurant itself was just plain dirty....food on the floor and all over the bar. Yuck!
Whispering Canyon Cafe was a fun restaurant and the food was good. Our son asked for ketchup and ended up with 7 or 8 bottles. We ordered the skillet and the burger.
The Spirit of Aloha dinner show food was very good. Well, except for the rice and that's only because we are from Louisiana and rice is supposed to be smothered in lots of gravy.
We also ate at the Grand Floridian Cafe. There wasn't a huge selection of foods to choose from but the steaks were fantastic.
50s Prime Time was a hoot! Our waiter was funny as were the waitresses around us. The food was like homecooked food but was tasty.
T-Rex was on the top of our list of "we wanna try" and it didn't disappoint. Yes, it was loud. Yes, the theming was over the top. But, our food was great and the service was pretty good even though the restaurant was busy.
And, then, we also ate at our favorites.....Coral Reef, Garden Grill and Crystal Palace.
For our upcoming trip, we have ADRs for the Plaza Restaurant, LeCellier and Hoop Dee Doo all of which we haven't been to in several years.