Just back from 10 days at AKL and our first night's dinner was at Boma. The theming was amazing. Of course there were no characters or anything like that, but with Disney's typical attention to details, the atmosphere was wonderful. DH enjoyed the food but the children and I ate primarily from the kids pod. The foods were more flavorful than what I like. The desserts were phenomenal! I am glad we did it, but do not feel the need to rush back.
Personally, if Chef Mickey's is your tradition then I would stick with that. You won't need a park ticket, it will get you in that "Disney mood" and you can take the bus to MK and then the monorail to Contemporary (my children think the monorail is a Disney ride). I suppose my family is accustomed to having to "travel" a bit to get places, but the 15 minute ride to MK did not bother us.
Another option might be Boardwalk. Beaches and Cream at the Beach Club? Spoodles? or as someone else mentioned - maybe Downtown Disney?