We did Liberty Tree tavern last time and while we really enjoyed it and would recommend (even with the glitch below), they didn't do the dress-up thing (maybe this is new? last time we went was 09) This year we are doing Liberty Tree Tavern again, but it was 2nd choice to Chef Mickey's. But we couldn't get a reservation there until 6:30.
Funny story about Liberty Tree last time...even though we had an ADR for the Diamond Horseshoe for that night, no one told the reservation people (or at least didn't tell the folks with ADR's) that they had rented out the Diamond Horseshoe for a private party. We had to wait over an hour and a half for our table. We sat down at 6:20.
I was worried we would be stuck in there for the start of the party, so I tipped our waiter $20 when he came to get our drink order. I told him, please feel free to bring everything at once, or as fast as you can. We don't need to have courses, please just bring food. (with a smile and a please of course) He was great!

Since it was only 2 of us, it wasn't a lot to handle. We had our salad, rolls, turkey & side dishes all at once within 5 minutes and he brought the check with dessert and we tipped him more for the effort.
To be honest, they were so busy from the overflow of ADR's from the Horseshoe, I think he was happy to clear a table so quickly. My husband and I got a kick out of the faces of people at one of the tables near us. It was a party of about 10 (what we will be this year) and they just looked in amazement as we ate, drank and left in 24 minutes.
I swear I've never tried anything like that before. But desperate times call for desperate measures

We still had time to be in the Haunted Mansion at 7pm for the start!
