Where should we eat on our DHS day?

[Disney Mom 7272]

I'm looking for suggestions for a table service meal on our DHS day - preferably for an early dinner so we can catch Fantasmic after. It doesn't have to be at DHS but could also be near the resorts our families are staying at - Pop and Carribbean Beach. We are a party of 10 w/ two toddlers, a five year old and infant. My SIL also has a gluten and dairy allergy. I've heard 50's Prime Time is great for accomdating GF allergies - any other options we should consider?

So far, I've got reservations at Sanaa, Ohana & Raglan Road for other days in our trip.

TIA!

We like Sci Fi in HS. Sebastian Bistro In Caribbean resort. My favorite restaurant is Ohana

 

[Gary Stocker]

Another vote for Mama Melrose's... I thought the steak was pretty good and I forgot what I had to drink but it had a glow cube

Also keep in mind you can package Mama Melrose's, Hollywood and Vine, and Brown Derby with Fantasmic for priority seating.

https://disneyworld.disney.go.com/dining/hollywood-studios/fantasmic-dining-package/

 

[Sandy Mouse]

We liked Mama Melrose's last year and Hollywood Brown Derby a couple of years ago. I can't decide between them for trip next spring.

 

[glocon]

My favorite meal ever was at MM. The saltimbocca was Devine!
We wanted to try the bd lounge last time but it was closed. 50s PT was ok, SF diner was ok, really liked MM though.

 

[SarahInMN]

Derby. Hands down derby if you want to stay in the park.

 

[GeorgiaHoo]

Mama Melrose. We've eaten there twice and it was good both times. Thought it was as least as good as Via Napoli, which people tend to like.

 

[mattpeto]

Sci-Fi is such a hard reservation to nab for some reason.

 

[hereforthechurros]

Need to please picky eaters with the classics? SciFi
Want fun atmosphere and comfort food? 50s PrimeTime
Quality of food top priority? Hollywood Brown Derby

 

[Amy11401]

We ate at Mama Melrose when we were at HS and liked it. I got the steak and it was wonderful!