For outstanding food and service, I would choose Flying Fish, Monsieur Paul or Yachtsman Steakhouse. Those three are on the more expensive side, but the quality would make for a memorable birthday dinner. A less expensive option is the Grand Floridian Cafe. It is a pretty setting, and the food is good. For a birthday dinner a while back the GFC presented a large hand-painted chocolate tile. I don’t know if that is still offered, but it was a nice birthday surprise for our table.