When can a dependent be taken off of family auto policies?

OP here. Thanks so much for the replies. We have asked about every scenario and they swear there is no way around this. We can put one car in his name and get his own policy with a separate co, but USAA won’t lower our rates on us adults/other vehicles regardless. We have one newer vehicle with full coverage and 3 older vehicles (all 20 plus years old) with lowest amount of liability possible, and we are paying over $11k a year. Even though the old cars aren’t worth anything, they are worth the world to us so I hate to stop using them. We may have to, though.

I know USAA is not the cheapest, but we had a house issue one time and I cannot believe how amazing they were. I guess we will shop around and see, but that’s so incredibly frustrating and time consuming. I have two more boys getting close to driving age.
Oh well, thank you all so much for the help!

Unless he moves out on his own permanently (college is considered transitory, which is why it is difficult to establish residency in the state they go to college if it's different than their home state), I don't think there's any way to remove him from your insurance policies.

Look at the insurance policy, it identifies the insured driver as the one whose vehicle the name is under for the declarations page. But if you look at the contents of the insurance policy, doesn't it cover all drivers who reside in the household?
 
If you are in PA, NJ, OH, CT or MD check out NJM. They offer a hefty discount for college students away over 100 miles from home without a vehicle. They uve a 10 month billing cycle so you would get two months off each year and so much more!
 
Each state and each company will have different parameters. In the state I work in and the company I work for you can make someone a non-operator in a case like this. We can also mark them away at school more than 100 miles w/o a car. So even if they came home on breaks, they are rated more like an occasional driver. Also, if they have a vehicle titled to them, then they can (and should) have their own policy.

I would shop around. It's a pain I know but sometimes you need to do it and see if you are paying too much or if it's really in line with your situation.

Another thing to know about insurance, is it's very personal. You many have the exact same situation as your best friend across town. Same age, same household drivers and types of vehicles. But you may pay completely different rates. It has to do with your garaging location, your insurance history (not claims or tickets but your history), the type of insurance you have carried (state minimums vs more coverage), they type of company(s) you have been with, etc. You have an insurance score much like a credit score.
 
Did you shop around for other quotes? $8500 sounds high. I have maximum coverage and with 3 young males it wasn't that high. NJ
I have a broker and she did shop around but my current carrier is the cheapest because I have bundle discounts with my homeowners. I neglected to say that that rate also includes an umbrella policy which is about $700 additional per year. I still feel like it is way too much.
 

I've been with the same insurance company since I got my license when I was 16, so 48 years. I gave up on price shopping. Yes, I can get a lower quote on auto, but to get that price, I have to bundle, and then the homeowners and or the umbrella policy rates or higher. Or the homeowners and the auto is cheaper but the umbrella is much more expensive. The individual policy rates vary, but the total cost for all my insurance policies always comes to less than $20 a year difference, so a waste of time to switch.
We always had excellent service and price with our company, which my wife had from when she left her parent's policy. We never did the insurance swap either. We'd never had a rise in premium from incidents over the years which includes a rollover. When we divorced, I stayed with the company after 7 quotes it was the cheapest (expensive as it's the same by myself as it was married.)

I have a weird situation to solve now. My daughter, 20 working student, just bought her first car. She was on mom's insurance but I cosigned a loan so I'm on the registration and title. She can't stay on mom's since the car is also in my name and wants her own policy. We don't know what the cost will be yet and I will compare with adding her to my insurance. She however lives with mom and not with me. I hope it doesn't come to were she needs to still be on mom's policy but not with this car.
 
We always had excellent service and price with our company, which my wife had from when she left her parent's policy. We never did the insurance swap either. We'd never had a rise in premium from incidents over the years which includes a rollover. When we divorced, I stayed with the company after 7 quotes it was the cheapest (expensive as it's the same by myself as it was married.)

I have a weird situation to solve now. My daughter, 20 working student, just bought her first car. She was on mom's insurance but I cosigned a loan so I'm on the registration and title. She can't stay on mom's since the car is also in my name and wants her own policy. We don't know what the cost will be yet and I will compare with adding her to my insurance. She however lives with mom and not with me. I hope it doesn't come to were she needs to still be on mom's policy but not with this car.

So long as you are the cosigner, you will probably also be the primary on the car. You, she and the bank have the insurable interest in the car, until it's paid for. So, doubtful she will remain on mom's policy. Just my opinion - not an expert by any stretch of my imagination.
 
Auto insurance has always baffled me. The one semester I got good enough grades for a Good Student discount they had stopped giving them.....because as the agent explained it......they discovered Good Students drive more and crash more. And my mom traded in her 1960 Buick Le Sabre on a new 1974 Buick Apollo (a Chevy Nova with a Buick name on it) she didn't qualify for a compact car discount because it only applied to cars less than 200 inches long. It was 201 inches long.
 
We had to start a new policy and we left the "kids" off. They told me all people over 16 in the house. Away at school, our address was still his primary. So... now we pay insurance on two cars 1 full coverage and one state minimum and its 125 a month with geico.
 
Our insurance company (AAA, Interagency Insurance Exchange) does not offer a reduced rate for students living away without a car. DS went to school out of state, and because it was so far away (900 miles and 5 states from here), we knew he would probably only come home for a few days at Christmas, so probably 2 weeks a year. Our agent told us that we would be paying a full year's premium to have him within reach of our cars for a whole 14 days, so over $100/day to cover him, which she said was crazy. She advised us to have him change his driver's license to his school address immediately when he moved to college, and that because it was an out of state license, there would be no problem removing him from the policy, and that for the few days he was home for holidays, we could let him drive our cars as a houseguest. Worked like a charm. While he was in school he just used their Enterprise car share (insurance included in the rate) if he needed a car for something, and otherwise rode his bike or took Lyft or Uber. We bought him a used car as a college graduation gift, and he insured that separately in his own name in the state where he lives. (I should note that when he changed his DL, he also put his school address on all his school records, student loans, voter registration and Selective Service registration, even his library cards, and he also relocated his bank accounts. It did not change his residency for tuition purposes because there was a waiting period for that, but for everything else, he had officially cut ties completely with this state. Our address appeared absolutely nowhere on any official documentation of his after that date.)

When he first insured the car on his own, the premium (with Progressive) was insanely high, but they told us that was because he had never been insured in his own name before, and that it would be eligible to be re-quoted after 6 months. After 6 months clean they reduced it by 30%, but at the end of the year they sent a bill that would have renewed it at the same rate. I helped him shop around, and actually did a fully new quote online with Progressive that came in 68% cheaper than the adjusted rate, having been a customer for a year with a completely clean record and no accidents or tickets ever, and that was considerably cheaper than all the other quotes he got. He also has a very high credit rating because I put him on one of my credit cards as an authorized user when he was 18, the card for emergency use only unless I gave him advance permission for something specific (like textbooks), which meant I paid it when he used it. He essentially nearly inherited my credit rating, and that also helped lower his rate quite a bit.
 
Last edited:
We live in GA. Our son is 19 and is a full time college student. He still lives at home on our address and drives to our local college. He drives an older model car that is paid for and titled in his name. He is on his own insurance policy. It was actually cheaper for him to have his own policy than to add him to ours. If you add him to yours then it looks like he has access to all the cars in your family.
 
Those extra cars are costing you a lot…. We have two cars insured through State Farm and we don’t have to add our kids to the policy (only one drives now) until we add another vehicle. Since DH and I work from home now (and into foreseeable future), two cars is plenty. Definitely not worth it for us to add any vehicles, we can all share.
 
We shopped around and opened a policy for our daughter with one car and a different company. Ours then automatically removed her from our policy.
 












Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top