We had the BEST time getting autographs on our last trip! We fixed up the small-sized Creative Memories scrapbooks for autographs with stickers, etc. That way we had special pages for each character. We added more pages when we got home for pictures. While the characters were talking/playing with DD's, they signed the books. We had both books open and pens ready for each character. That made it go much more smoothly.
Some of our funnest memories of our trip were from getting the autographs. Captain Hook was hysterical, making a big deal over having to sign on a page with Peter Pan's sticker! He had the whole line laughing. When we later got Peter Pan's signature, he messed around with Hook's signature and made a "stinking codfish" out of part of the signature! It was great! DD's have loved looking at the signatures over the last couple of years.
They are already planning on getting autographs again on our upcoming trip. Oldest DD is 12 and more excited about it now than the first time around!