There is a Sizzlin' Grill (NOT a Sizzler) right across Highway 192 from Old Town. $3.99 for breakfast buffet, no crowds (which happens at Sizzler) and very good service. They also have a lunch and dinner buffet. Dinner has steak and seafood (but it's not that great so lunch is definitely a better bargain).
Totally agree....growing up this is where we always went every summer when we were there. Love it there...it has probably changed but the memories are still there of chocolate chip pancakes and scrambled eggs and ham yum yum
There's also a Perkins about a block beyond the Bob Evans. We prefer Perkins (I prefer their coffee). In fairness and full disclosure: Perkins is sort of a family tradition and we plan our road trip stops around them.