What would Simon say? (American Idol ?)

[KristiKelly]

What would Simon say to Bob Dylan if he was a contestant on American Idol? I was scanning the stations in my car earlier and Bob Dylan was on, I wondered what Simon's critic would be

 

[Robinrs]

"My God, that was just AWFUL! You shouldn't have made it this far, that was PAINFUL..."

 

[battricia]

That's a great picture!!

tricia.

 

[olena]

LOL! Didn't you see the SNL sketch about that? It was a commercial for AI's new season which would feature established stars. Simon let them have it. He told Madonna to lose the accent. I can't remember who else he was ripping on....maybe Britney or Aguilera, but it was HILARIOUS!

 

[GeorgeG]

I only wish there was someone like Simon back then to tell Dylan he can't sing! Nothing makes me turn the radio off faster than a Bob Dylan song coming on. The guy can't even play a harmonica in tune!

Funny thing, though... a friend of mine loaned me a tape of Dylan and Johnny Cash together and they weren't bad. I can only figure that they made each other sound better by each being so bad.

I'm not saying these guys don't have any talent, but it's sure not singing.