I grew up going to WDW numerous times. We always stayed offsite in very nice hotels. My first REAL onsite experience (not counting DTD hotels) was ASmo (with my DH and DS).
I was EXPECTING to be disappointed because of all the bad "press" the AS get on these boards. I'm not the "budget-motel" type, so not having extra amenities in the room kind of "stuck out" right away. Housekeeping made up for it by being so attentive and arranging our stuffed animals ,etc. You don't get that kind of care at a cheap motel.
Other than that, I thought it was GREAT!!! Cute theming landscaping, pool, pool bar, awesome food court (not what I expected) and an overall "fun" atmosphere. I almost expected to see people moping around with , "I'm so depressed because I can't afford the GF" looks. None of that at all!
It definitely set a standard. ASSp was nice, but I don't care much about the theming. My next stay was at CBR. I loved the room (big and more of those amenities).
AKL was a dream come true, and CSR is the perfect mix of elegance and affordability! I don't see myself "not liking" any WDW Resort.