"REAL TALK MOMENT: If it were up to me, I wouldn’t start talking about these potential winter storms until a few days out and that’s what we (TV Broadcast Meteorologists) used to do before social media. Over the past several years, social media weather wannabes started posting model data 10 to 14 days out. Also, winter storm watches are now being issued 4-5 days out.
I now now have no choice but to talk about it, even if we know it may not happen based on my past experience with similar systems and climatology. And if I don’t talk about it, I get told that we’re afraid of being wrong, when the reality is, we know there’s no guarantee that it’s going to happen and the model data is probably gonna change.
Hopefully, that helps folks understand our dilemma when it comes to forecasting snow and ice. None of this is as black and white or as simple as people think it should be. All the different variables involved in forecasting winter weather alone are super complex and nearly any southern winter system is going to have a large potential to change even within 24 hours of the event."
That seems to be very specific to your area that may not get stuff often. The last line about changing within 24hrs of an event for is applicable to many different areas not just the south. The way the jet stream, rivers or lakes, specific location a place is, topography of the land, etc all often influence a system such that it can change within a few hours of an expected event. Where I live that IS the norm because where we are in the middle of the country is influenced by both Canada and Mexico all the time. And in my case it's often "south of I-70"= X north of I-70=Y, or at times west of I-35=X, eat of I-35=Y.
Another take to your weatherman you're talking about is the other side of the coin. The fact that when more knowledge is given more safety can be taken. It's like talking about tornadoes, you can't predict them with any sort of real advancement, they are wildly random, but advance warning systems have done a tremendous help in reducing the deaths in such events.
The most advanced weathermen will still talk about long-range models but they won't inject confidence in them, they'll talk about a potential for a particular weather pattern in the coming weeks. They are helpful for learning weather patterns as the years go on by, learning how norm weather patterns change too. I don't think the person you're talking about is giving their due diligence to their own industry by calling people wannabe social media weather people and connecting it to long-range models. There is a subset of people who are less or not trained at all but they shouldn't be lumped into a category like the person you quoted said.
Weather is always unpredictable no matter where you live no system can really be predicted without unknowns or with certainty, timing is often one of the most difficult things to predict. From when a system shifts over from rain to snow or doesn't even have rain to begin with first (which is better for pre-treatment around my area). So there is such a thing as too much forecast
with confidence but at least in my area if they only started talking about things these days only a few days out it would not be better, it would be worse. They just don't know what a system will be like but they should start talking about it early enough to give people time to prepare including schools and businesses.