I was always excited to have days left on my park hopper tix... that means you -have- to come back to use them
Just glancing at debs all ears... she's got the pricing for 4 day park hopper, no exp for 2 adults and 1 child at about 879 dollars... which breaks down to just about 220 per day to get into the park for the remaining life of the park hopper. So spending the 200 to get the 1 day ticket will actually be a little cheaper by about 20 bucks, in my estimations!!
Except really you probably wouldn't buy another 4 day park hopper, you'd probably buy another 10 day when the first park hopper expires... the 10 day is a total of 1287 for your family, which is just 128.70 per day. Sooo if you are only going to buy 10 day park hoppers, then you're actually losing like 71 dollars if you buy the 1 day ticket for 200.
However... it's hard to say what the dining plan is actually -worth- to you. Everyone says they feel like they save money on it for the amt of food you get. But maybe you would prefer not to have all that food anyways? Or maybe you do like to have all the food and it would actually save you over 70 dollars for your trip? Hhrrrmmmm....
I guess maybe just decide how important it is for you to have the dining plan and don't worry about the ticket prices so much. If you've enjoyed the plan in the past, go for it! If you felt maybe it wasn't for you, then maybe just use the park hoppers up?
Hope this helped some! I think I feel more confused....... LOL

I'm sure whatever you decide, you'll have a fantastic trip!!