What a fun forum! I will say everyone has different tastes and that is why I love Disney so much!
I also like to give things 2 chances at least to see if maybe I was mistake the first time - like Tower of Terror - bad experience the first time, then loved it the 2nd.
I have 3 things for this list:
BOMA - just a very average buffet, actually I would rate it below avg especially considering the price. Tried it twice - dinner and breakfast. Dinner was slightly better - breakfast was pathetic. Do not get how people like this over the 100s of other better choices in Disney.
Soarin - 3 times tried, each time, I left saying - just what am I missing? Nothing special at all about this ride, it is like any other Imax theater.
Dole whip - only tried once here - but so gross, can not even fathom trying it again. This one may be more just personal taste and I can see why some people might like it, but again, so many better choices at least for my taste buds.