I'm terrible with this, I have so many. Although I cut back, I still have a bunch.
A rubberized Tinkerbell from Walt Disney World (I hadda have one!), two Tiffany's heart keychains (different designs, my ex-boyfriend and my best friend each got me one when I passed my road test without knowing the other one had), a Victoria's Secret mini-shopping bag (all my friends have one), and a Northeastern University lanyard.