What kind of feedback? Seller "lost item" that I won.

shades

DIS Veteran
Joined
Nov 15, 2005
Messages
1,028
I won an auction with 2 items listed and both appear to have pictures taken at the same time for the auction (same junk surrounding both items). Both items in the auction are listed individually in other auctions, although - one of the items is a bit more difficult to find. I think I got lucky because the seller didn't title their auction very well.

So, anyway - I paid immediately for the auction and less than 24hrs later, I received an email stating that "one of their staff has pulled one of the items out of the box labeled for the auction and they can't find it." They offered to replace the item (of course, it was the piece that is more difficult to find) with a different item (a very common item that rarely sells and there are a bozillian of them) or, they would give me a refund. I opted for the refund. They appologized, and they cancelled my payment so now it looks like I didn't even send them a payment according to Ebay. However, I can still leave feedback.

Needless to say, I'm disappointed and a little frustrated that they have done this. I understand that people list items and then find that they listed it by mistake. But - this seller only has about 215 feedback total with no more than 10-15 auctions at a time and their items look like the photos were taken in a junky garage (hardly a seller going to power seller status or Ebay store status). According to their feedback, they look to be buyers way more frequently than sellers.

So, given the circumstances, what kind of feedback would you leave?

Neutral - because it could have been a genuine mistake and they didn't just recently realize they could make more money for the one item they have "lost" - or

Positive - because they did give me a full refund.

What would y'all do? :confused3
 
It depends. I might keep an eye out, see if they list that same item again. If they do, THEN leave negative for sure.

If they really did lose the item, it happens. Especially us occasional sellers don't have great systems in place, and are a little foggy about getting auctions listed and up there. I don't think I would leave a neutral OR a positive. If they don't list that same item again (which would be quite suspicious), maybe leave no feedback at all. That won't help them nor hinder them.
 
Try to only judge them by the facts at hand: they notified you promptly, they apologized, offered two choices to fix the problem, and refunded in full as you requested. You don't HAVE to leave them any feedback; in this case, I would just leave it be and not leave feedback. However, if you do leave feedback, I would make it POSITIVE and just say something like, "Honest seller. Refunded payment when item was lost."

They may have had two of the item; I often use the same photo of an item I have multiples of if they are exactly the same. Taking pictures is time-consuming; why bother taking two of the same item?

Save the negatives for the true thiefs who don't ship items or send damaged goods!
 
As a seller, I would have to admit that I have done such before. Usually it was things I had multiples of and somehow I sold more than I had. Also on clothing, as I was packaging, I noticed a stain or something that I had overlooked before I listed. I always refund promptly and email the buyer.
I have only one time had a hostile buyer who gave me a negative. The rest has given a positive or nothing at all.
As a buyer, I will leave a positive because I have been on both ends and certainly understand that mistakes happen.
As mentioned earlier, I may wait to make sure the same item is not listed again. As this does happen when it does not go for as much as they hoped for.
Whatever you choose to do, just stick to the facts.
 
As a seller I went through a similar situation a couple of years ago. I sold a small Longaberger basket on eBay. I went out to dinner and came home to find that the dogs had taken it off of the desk and chewed it up!! :crazy: I immediately emailed the buyer, apoligized and refunded the money. The buyer was understanding, but disappointed.

It sounds to me like the seller made an honest mistake, these things happen. I would say either leave a postive feedback because they handled the problem promptly and professionally, or leave none at all.
 
I'd either leave positive for the reasons mentioned, or nothing at all. I'd give them the benefit of the doubt. They handled it pretty well, IMO.
 
I agree with the pp's that either positive feedback listing the facts or nothing at all would be a good choice. I appreciate honesty in sellers too and since you can't prove they didn't lose the item I would take their word for it. I'm just happy you got your money back :) Negative feedback would definitely be in order if they failed to issue you a refund!
 
Thanks everybody!

I've decided to not leave any feedback at all. Just because she gave me a full refund, I still don't think she warrants positive feedback. The transaction wasn't completed. However, neutral feedback seems kind of harsh at this point. So, I'll move on and look elsewhere.

:thumbsup2 :cool1:
 
I would not leave feedback. But I would check on her auctions to see if she tries to relist it, if they were being untruthful.
 
you could say error made by seller.. but seller took care of it A+ and leave positive! I am sure she would rather you leave nothing though.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom