I won an auction with 2 items listed and both appear to have pictures taken at the same time for the auction (same junk surrounding both items). Both items in the auction are listed individually in other auctions, although - one of the items is a bit more difficult to find. I think I got lucky because the seller didn't title their auction very well.
So, anyway - I paid immediately for the auction and less than 24hrs later, I received an email stating that "one of their staff has pulled one of the items out of the box labeled for the auction and they can't find it." They offered to replace the item (of course, it was the piece that is more difficult to find) with a different item (a very common item that rarely sells and there are a bozillian of them) or, they would give me a refund. I opted for the refund. They appologized, and they cancelled my payment so now it looks like I didn't even send them a payment according to Ebay. However, I can still leave feedback.
Needless to say, I'm disappointed and a little frustrated that they have done this. I understand that people list items and then find that they listed it by mistake. But - this seller only has about 215 feedback total with no more than 10-15 auctions at a time and their items look like the photos were taken in a junky garage (hardly a seller going to power seller status or Ebay store status). According to their feedback, they look to be buyers way more frequently than sellers.
So, given the circumstances, what kind of feedback would you leave?
Neutral - because it could have been a genuine mistake and they didn't just recently realize they could make more money for the one item they have "lost" - or
Positive - because they did give me a full refund.
What would y'all do?
So, anyway - I paid immediately for the auction and less than 24hrs later, I received an email stating that "one of their staff has pulled one of the items out of the box labeled for the auction and they can't find it." They offered to replace the item (of course, it was the piece that is more difficult to find) with a different item (a very common item that rarely sells and there are a bozillian of them) or, they would give me a refund. I opted for the refund. They appologized, and they cancelled my payment so now it looks like I didn't even send them a payment according to Ebay. However, I can still leave feedback.
Needless to say, I'm disappointed and a little frustrated that they have done this. I understand that people list items and then find that they listed it by mistake. But - this seller only has about 215 feedback total with no more than 10-15 auctions at a time and their items look like the photos were taken in a junky garage (hardly a seller going to power seller status or Ebay store status). According to their feedback, they look to be buyers way more frequently than sellers.
So, given the circumstances, what kind of feedback would you leave?
Neutral - because it could have been a genuine mistake and they didn't just recently realize they could make more money for the one item they have "lost" - or
Positive - because they did give me a full refund.
What would y'all do?

I immediately emailed the buyer, apoligized and refunded the money. The buyer was understanding, but disappointed.
Negative feedback would definitely be in order if they failed to issue you a refund!
Too funny! That is probably what I would do!