I will try to answer you the best I can. Remember everyone, this is only MY opinion, so no flames.

Okay, we did the Blue Lagoon Island excursion, and we were soooo excited about surprising my twin girls, age 10 to the dolphin encounter there. Well, we got over there and was herded towards the dolphin encounter with most of the people on our slow moving ferry boat that took 45 minutes to get over there. It was beautiful- the trip over, so I am really not trying to complain about that part. So we get up to the encounter "classroom" type thing where they are telling about where to touch the dolphins, what not to touch, etc, etc. Everyone during this time was loud and really not listening to him talk. I was mad they didn't make people SHUT UP during this, so we could at least hear what is going on. So then he got done talking and must've said something about come this way becasue all of a sudden I was getting trampled on and pushed out of the way. So I got the hint and followed the crowd. They divided us up to several U shaped piers and there was probably 12 people per section, 6 on each side. They had 6 people go to the bottom of the U where there is a platform in the water. You stand there and she called the dolphin in, and had the dolphin come by you to pet it, then again to dance with it, then again to get your "kiss" while the phtographer took a picture (it is per family, not per person, so decide before this time who is going to be the one to get "kissed". Anyway, it was....neat, but IMHO not worth that much MONEY!! WOW that was an expensive 2-3 minutes that my twins got to actually touch and see up close the dolphin. I mean if you add up all the minutes together. Anyway, after that we did the Stingray City which was so VERY COOL! I can't say enough about it- maybe its becasue it was my first time to "snorkel" at ALL, but it was really neat! For $15 it was so much more worth it than the $118.00 per kid for the dolphin theng, and my kids love dolphins, but I bet if you asked them when I wasn't around which they liked best, it would be the stingrays! So, to answer your question.....lets see would I do it again........I don't think I would go to Blue Lagoon Island again, the stingray thing was quite COOL, but I would probably choose stay on the ship, the beach at Blue Lagoon Island was nice, peaceful, quiet, pretty, etc, but boy I hadn't seen ANYTHING til we got to
Castaway Cay!!
Whew, that was alot, thanks for listening.....hee hee