Ok, after spending more than a week reading this thread, I have my own contributions:
I've never had a Dole Whip, nor ever even heard of one till I discovered this thread. Would be willing to try one once.
I've never had a turkey leg (always been full or going to dinner when the opportunity arose) but would like to try one at least once.
I absolutely MUST HAVE a frozen banana while at MK.
I tear up (yes Im a guy) when we first get to MK and I see the castle!
I wish the movie Song of the South were available on DVD/Blu-Ray so my kids can see it and then learn to appreciate the Splash Mountain movie better. (My favourite ride)
Christmas at Disney is nice, but not the same feeling without real snow like at home.
Im planning our next 3 trips to Orlando this December, December 2011 and December 2012! (Even though the schedules are not out yet!)
I think that IASW is one of the classic rides that should never change and everyone should ride at least once! Best ride was last December when we took my 75yr old mom along for the ride after 30 yrs of not going to the MK.
During our stay at All Star Movies, we swam in the pools of Fort Wilderness & Animal Kingdom and toured each resort. Now Im in love with Fort Wilderness, want to stay there sometime, but cant justify double the expense.
I want to wear a Mickey Mouse watch.
While in a store along Main Street, my 2 ½ yr old grabbed a Lightning McQueen car ornament. I let him hold onto it to keep him occupied. I noticed he still was carrying it as we were getting onto our shuttle bus back to our hotel that evening. I forgot to return it before we left the store! (He was wearing a rain poncho and not easy to see)
oh I once left the stroller with the baby in it to run across the walk to get a picture with Belle!
I did that same thing with my then 1.5 yr old at HWS, left DW with older 2 kids at Narnia screening while I lined up for Indiana Jones. Parked the stroller, took him out, but forgot to bring him with me! 5 min later, I found him happily standing where I had left him.
As much as adults can go to WDW alone, I feel I need my kids with me. They are getting older now so Im trying to convince DW to have another baby, so we can have more trips to the World.
My first time riding Dumbo I was 43.
That's because we spell it properly in England!!!

And here in Canada eh!
Dont have cable or satellite, just a roof mounted antenna so we cant get the Disney Channel. Might break the budget someday just to get that channel for the kids.
Get very mad at parents who drag their toddlers way past their bedtimes, it's obvious they are exhausted, but the parent insists on 'getting their money's worth'. Wish I could take those kids home and put them to bed properly.
Ok it's long, but I think I got all of it.