I can't speak for other areas of the country, but here is an article from our local paper that might put things into perspective (at least for the Phila subburbs):
Teachers should consider themselves fortunate
The newspaper story reported that seven Bucks County public school districts and technical schools are among the top 10 in the state for highest average teacher salaries.
That shouldn't surprise too many people around here. Pennsylvania ranks ninth among the states with an average teacher salary of more than $53,000, so it figures that affluent Bucks County would exceed the state average.
Council Rock has the highest average teacher paycheck at $84,612 annually. It was followed by Neshaminy ($81,816), Bensalem ($78,885), Pennsbury ($78,047), Middle Bucks technical school ($76,863) Upper Bucks technical school ($74,906) and Quakertown ($74,375).
Centennial was 20th in the state at $70,642. New Hope-Solebury ($70,154) ranked 22nd, and Pennridge ($70,153) was 23rd.
Well, everybody knows teachers here are paid well, and it doesn't really matter how we feel about their compensation because it is what it is.
But teacher pay needs to be put into some kind of perspective.
The U.S. Department of Labor tracks a lot of data about the work force, including salaries and hours worked.
If you look at its statistics for the Philadelphia Metropolitan Region in 2007, which includes Southeastern Pennsylvania and parts of South Jersey and northern Delaware, you can see how teacher pay stacks up against that of other professionals and workers with similar levels of education.
These are mean figures, that is to say, averages, so some people earn more and others less.
For example, physicians in our region, according to the Labor Department, earn an average annual salary of $129,638. Lawyers on average take in $109,113.
Registered nurses make an average of $64,963, while engineers earn an average of $81,798.
Teachers throughout the wide metropolitan region, though, earn an average of $53,918, which is on a par with the statewide average.
It's also on a par with police officers, who earn an average of $53,783.
But there is more at which to look, namely, the amount of time spent earning that money.
The Labor Department says that, in our metropolitan region, lawyers work an average of 2,107 hours a year. The average annual total for engineers is 2,101, for police officers (2,072), registered nurses (2,031), and physicians (2,016).
Teachers, however, work an average of just 1,445 hours a year, due to the fact that they work about 10 fewer weeks a year than almost everyone else.
But if you look at salary in terms of hourly earnings, the salary picture for teachers becomes brighter.
Physicians earn an average of $64.30 an hour, lawyers ($51.79), engineers ($38.94), teachers ($37.32), registered nurses ($31.99) and police officers ($25.96).
The picture is brighter still for those fortunate enough to be employed in some of those affluent Bucks County districts.
An average salary of $84,612 in Council Rock, divided by 1,445 hours a year comes out to $58.55 an hour. That's more than the average lawyer in the region makes ($51.79) and almost as much as the average physician ($64.30).
Now, I know some of you will fault my methodology.
Teachers have to do preparatory work outside the scope of the typical work day. But all professionals work late at the office after hours or take work home with them.
And someone might successfully argue that, just as teachers in Bucks might earn more than the regional average, so do Bucks lawyers, doctors and other professionals.
In fairness it also must be said that most teachers I know admit that, while well educated, they don't possess the specialized training and skills that doctors and lawyers have and don't feel they should be compensated at a level equal to those specialties.
The point is, nevertheless, that they are well compensated and they should rejoice in their good fortune.
All jobs have their unique set of pressures. Teachers have a lot of responsibilities, but so do nurses and police officers.
Teachers should feel proud of their profession, and they should believe that we're proud of them, too.
Most people want them to do a good job. It's an important one, and one for which they should be fairly compensated. We want them to be happy.
It's just that they make us unhappy when they cry poor when contract negotiations roll around. They shouldn't feel sorry for themselves because they're far from being poor. We certainly don't feel sorry for them, nor should we.
They should be happy, and certainly they should be realistic.
After all, compared with many others of similar educational backgrounds, they have it pretty good.
Lou Sessinger is a columnist with The Intelligencer and phillyBurbs.com. He can be contacted at (215) 957-8172 or
lsessinger@phillyBurbs.com.