After reading this thread I had to try it. We returned from WDW last night. It was EXCELLENT for counter service! We went straight upstairs (after learning about it on this thread) and we were the only people up there. We sat in a corner with a window overlooking the entrance to Haunted Mansion, where we could also see the Steam Boat, and out the other window we watched the 3pm parade. How cool was that?! DS7 had the kids mac & cheese meal & I had the Anchors Aweigh tuna snadwich - very very good. We chose to eat here for a quick bite on another day as well. They were getting ready to close so the upstairs was roped off, I was disappointed. But the downstairs wasn't full, and I had the same sandwich. It was a nice refreshing meal on a hot day. We will definitely eat here every time we're in MK from now on!