chiming in here

. just wanted to agree with all of the other pp's regarding this lovely resort. we honeymooned there - along with kauai - 8 years ago and LOVED it! we were in an oceanview suite that was AMAZING! we paid rack rates

as this was many moons before we knew what a timeshare was - let alone DVC.
we also highly recommend kimo's for dinner. they had some dessert there - the name escapes me, but the memory of something insanely delicious does not!
snorkeling molokini crater was one of the highlights of our trip. we loved it so much that we ended up buying our own snorkel gear while there and found all sorts of secluded beaches and inlets to explore and snorkel on our own.
we took helicopter tours on two islands, and were not too impressed with the tour on maui.
car rental is a must as there was not public transportation on kauai and maui for the things we wanted to do. if you are "resort vacationers" - those that do not leave the resort (believe me, we met so many who did not step foot off property), then a car is probably not necessary. if you are into exploring, the rent the car. we did drive to lahaina, but parking was no picnic - esp at night. the old lahaina luau was great, but i agree - book this way in advance. downtown lahaina was fun - lots to do at night.
we found some wonderful guidebooks for our stay - the authors were entertaining and full of knowledge about things to see "off the beaten path". in fact, we did do the road to hana, but never made it to the seven sacred pools as we found so many hidden gems along the way! don't remember the authors, but the book title for this island was "
maui revealed". don't know if there has been a recent edition, but we carried this thing like a preacher carries a bible! it was a infinitely helpful and entertaining at the same time. the authors pinpoint descriptions led us to the most amazing places that we never would have otherwise found.
whew! i totally rambled. guess i need to get back there asap - maybe for my 10 year annv???
have fun!