We stayed at WL once and loved it. We then tried AKL and loved it even more. It is similarly priced and setup as a lodge. Plus there are bunk beds there as well for the kids.
we ended up picking Coronado. It was the least expensive moderate with free dining still available during our dates. excited to try something new but I might need to go over to WL for a visit at least
We have stayed at WL, AKL, CSR, POFQ, BLT, BWV, and BCV and there is something we love about them all! I think you will enjoy CSR very much...it has a very peaceful vibe, the pool is great, and the Pepper Market is VERY good for CS. The only thing you may not enjoy is that transportation is strictly by bus, but we honestly didn't have a problem with the buses there...and our kids actually enjoy riding the WDW buses!